Greens accused of ‘petty politics’ after walking out of Holyrood debate on Queen’s Jubilee

Republican campaigners praise ‘extraordinary’ move

Adam Forrest
Thursday 02 June 2022 13:32 EDT
Comments
Scottish Green Party co-leaders Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater
Scottish Green Party co-leaders Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater (PA)

Scottish Green party MSPs were accused of “petty student politics” after walking out en masse of a parliamentary debate celebrating the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee.

The Scottish Conservatives condemned the boycott after all seven Green representatives left the Holyrood chamber as first minister Nicola Sturgeon led tributes to Her Majesty.

But Republican campaigners praised the move – arguing that it reflected the anti-monarchist views of many young people in Scotland.

“I think it’s quite extraordinary,” said Graham Smith, head of the Republic group. “There are big political changes across the whole of the UK and certainly in Scotland. It wouldn’t have happened 10 years ago.”

Co-leaders Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater – who are Scottish government ministers – led the Greens’ walk-out on Wednesday. A spokesperson said the party’s MSPs believed in an elected head of state.

The spokesperson said: “We respect others hold different beliefs. Our MSPs decided to absent themselves from today’s short debate and instead spend their time serving their constituents.”

Sharon Dowey, the Scottish Tories’ shadow minister for culture, said the refusal to thank the Queen for seven decades of services was “petty, student politics at its worst”.

She added: “Their transparent attempt to woo anti-monarchy voters will only frustrate the vast majority of Scots who recognise this weekend’s Jubilee celebrations as a chance to show our gratitude for Her Majesty’s tireless dedication.”

The SNP leader led the tributes to Queen Elizabeth II at Holyrood, with Ms Sturgeon saying she had played an “integral role” in the story of modern Scotland and urging Scots to mark her “values of integrity, wisdom, justice and compassion”.

Meanwhile, the Stormont leader of Irish nationalist party Sinn Fein was move to write to the Queen on the occasion of the Platinum Jubilee.

Vice president Michelle O’Neill wrote to the Queen to praise her “significant” contribution to the peace process and to acknowledge her “dedicated public service to the British people” during her 70 years on the throne.

Ms O’Neill also thanked the Queen for her “warmth and unfailing courtesy” on the occasions when the pair have met and wrote of the “value and respect” she had for the monarch’s contribution to reconciliation.

Former DUP leader Dame Arlene Foster praised Ms O’Neill’s gesture while DUP MLA Paul Givan, who also served as first minister, said it showed the progress that had been achieved in Northern Ireland in recent years.

Foster – given a damehood as part of the Jubilee honours – said: “I think for republicans, like Michelle O’Neill … they have recognised in Her Majesty the Queen the first of those, the fact that she has given so much service to the country.”

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in