The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. 

The best sleep supplements to help you get a full night’s rest

Sleep is crucial for good health and these supplements will help you get the rest you need

Emilie Lavinia
Fitness and wellbeing editor
Thursday 12 September 2024 11:33
Comments
These editor-approved picks will help you get the rest you need
These editor-approved picks will help you get the rest you need (iStock/The Independent)
Our Top Picks

If you struggle to get the recommended hours of sleep per night, you’re not alone. Sleep might seem like the most natural thing in the world – we’re hardwired to do it, after all. However, it’s estimated that close to one in five people in the UK experience sleep troubles, according to research from Mental Health UK.

Lack of sleep can not only leave you feeling tired, unfocused and irritable, it can also impact your overall health. Our bodies do most of their vital recovery and cell renewal during sleep so poor sleep long term can impact your vital functions like immunity and hormone regulation.

According to sleep experts at Emma, “During sleep, the body repairs and regenerates tissue, strengthens the immune system by enabling specialised immune cells – T Cells – to work more efficiently at fighting infections, and restores energy levels, while also enhancing brain functions, such as memory consolidation, decision-making, problem-solving, and creativity, and playing a vital role in regulating our mood and emotions.”

For many people, the issue isn’t how much time they spend in bed, it’s the quality of their sleep. Broken sleep or poor quality sleep can be just as much of a concern as too few hours. The time we spend in deep sleep and REM sleep matters to our overall recovery so if you’re constantly waking up in the night or you spend the majority of your night in a light sleep, this can impact your wellbeing dramatically.

Supplements and natural remedies have been used for thousands of years to support quality sleep and today, we can look to a raft of scientific studies that show exactly how these ingredients affect the brain and body. You’ll probably be familiar with plants like chamomile and valerian, which boast natural sedative effects, and nutrients like magnesium which regulates melatonin – the sleep hormone that influences the sleep and wake cycle.

Sleep supplements usually contain a blend of these ingredients to relax the body, kickstart the sleep cycle and support our natural ability to rest and recover. These products are safe to use and can lend a helping hand when your sleep is disturbed, be it due to stress, your surroundings or health conditions – anything from poor air quality in a room, to anxious thoughts or menopause symptoms can impact your sleep and affect how you feel the next day.

We tested supplements, drinks and tinctures from trusted brands to determine which sleep aids were the best and which stood up to the challenge of ensuring a better night’s rest.

How we tested

We tested every sleep supplement from trusted brands
We tested every sleep supplement from trusted brands (Emilie Lavinia)

As with any supplement or natural remedy, it can take time to see results. Our fitness and wellbeing editor tested each sleep formula in isolation for two weeks to experience the full effect. However, some of the products on this list have been in her sleep line-up for many years.

Several factors were taken into account including ingredients and formula, price, packaging and each supplement’s effect on the time it took to fall asleep, sleeping through the night, deep sleep, light sleep and REM sleep (which was tracked using a sleep tracking device) and hours spent asleep. Some sleep aids can leave you feeling a little groggy in the morning so that was taken into account too. Read on for the best sleep supplements and which impressed the most.

The best sleep supplements for 2024 are:

JSHealth PM+ lavender and chamomile formula

JS-health-sleep-supplement-indybest (1).png
  • Best: Overall
  • Volume: 30 tablets
  • How to take: Take one tablet with your evening meal
  • Why we love it
    • Contains 151g of magnesium
  • Take note
    • Strong lavender smell

These sleep supplements contain a blend of lavender, chamomile, passionflower and magnesium to relax the body and trigger the healthy release of melatonin to kickstart the sleep process. Magnesium also supports bone health and helps your muscles to repair while you rest and can soothe aches and pains in the process.

The supplements are perhaps a little more intimidating than others you might have taken, they’re on the larger side so if you struggle to swallow pills they might not be the best choice for you. However, with 151g of magnesium per pill, they do make an impact.

Our tester used to suffer from horrible sleep issues and has been taking the PM+ for several years. These supplements are part of the protocol that has fixed those issues. When taking them, we found we fell asleep very quickly and woke up feeling way more refreshed. We also noticed the difference when we stopped taking them.

Because they contain lavender, these supplements have quite a strong scent so if you don’t like the smell of lavender they might not be your first choice. They’re also a deep black colour which can stain your tongue a little if you don’t swallow them quickly. Overall we rated them the best for a restful night’s sleep so if you can swallow large pills they’re a great choice.

Back to top

Myvitamins sleep

myvitamins sleep supplements
  • Best: Budget buy
  • Volume: 30 servings
  • How to take it: Take three capsules 30-60 minutes before bed
  • Why we love it
    • Added zinc and B6
    • Affordable

If you’re looking for a more affordable formula, Myvitamins is always a good place to look. This sleep supplement rings in at £12.99 so is a good starting point if you’re trying sleep supplements for the first time and want to dip your toe. The bottle says it contains 30 servings and the brand recommends that one serving is three capsules per day.

Formulated with 200mg of magnesium and L-theanine, these capsules also contain plant-based extracts to help with sleep including, including montmorency cherry powder and lemon balm.

When compared to other supplements from leading brands, we found them to be pretty decent. They contain all the usual suspects along with added zinc and vitamin B6. They also contain L-tryptophan, which is an essential amino acid responsible for the production of serotonin. Clearly aimed at gym bunnies, these supplements will really work hard to help your body repair and regulate itself while you sleep. We slept well while taking them and woke up feeling refreshed with less pain from the gym.

Back to top

Inessa Magnesium

Inessa magnesium sleep supplement
  • Best: Magnesium supplement
  • Volume: 60 tablets
  • How to take: Take one tablet 30 minutes before bed
  • Why we love it
    • Contains 153g of magnesium
    • Great for reducing pain and inflammation
  • Take note
    • No other sleep aid ingredient

Some people find that when they take magnesium before bed they wake up feeling sleepy. This wasn’t the case when we tested these supplements from Inessa. In fact we woke up feeling refreshed and ready to take on the day.

These tablets also boast a high volume of bioavailable magnesium from purified seawater as well as magnesium bis-glycinate and magnesium threonate. Magnesium can bind to compounds called phytates which can make it harder for the body to absorb but Inessa uses a chelated form of magnesium and no fillers or additives to ensure you get the full impact of what’s in the pill.

We’ve been taking these tablets for about a year to help with sleep but also to stave off DOMS after exercise. Women shouldn’t take more than 220mg of magnesium a day and this supplement offers 153g which is great alongside a balanced diet. While taking it, we sleep deeply and wake up more energised and less achy and fatigued.

The tablets are easy to swallow but don’t contain any other sleep-promoting ingredients. It’s just magnesium, pure and simple.

Back to top

Earth’s Secret sleep complex

earths secret sleep supplement
  • Best: For falling asleep quickly
  • Volume: 60 capsules
  • How to take it: Take one to two capsules an hour before bed
  • Why we love it
    • Contains saffron and tart cherry

These sleep complex supplements contain 120mg of tart cherry, which is packed with natural melatonin. This can boost your body’s natural levels and help you naturally relax and begin the sleep process. Our experience of taking these capsules showed real promise when it came to the time it took to fall asleep.

Other ingredients like lavender soothe the body along with chamomile, which is a natural sedative. The capsules also contain saffron, which is a natural mood booster but it can also support better quality sleep.

Studies on the Earth’s Secret website show the impact of each ingredient on sleep, including passionflower which can increase the level of ‘GABA’ in your brain – this is a neurotransmitter that slows brain activity and enables you to switch off naturally.

We found that while taking these supplements we fell asleep quickly, logged more hours of deep sleep with my sleep tracking device and woke up feeling well rested. The ingredients are perfectly balanced and we rated this supplement for a quick wind down.

Back to top

Welleco The evening elixir

welleco the evening elixir
  • Best: Bedtime drink
  • Volume: 150g
  • How to take it: Mix 2 teaspoons with 200ml of water or your milk of choice
  • Why we love it
    • Rich flavour
    • Low calorie
    • Contains magnesium
  • Take note
    • Not very sweet

If swallowing tablets before bed sounds like something you’d rather not do you could try taking your supplements in a different form. The evening elixir by Elle Macpherson’s wellness brand Welleco is a straightforward powder that you mix with liquid to create a tasty sippable sleep supplement.

Made with 100 per cent certified organic, fairly traded cocoa beans, it’s basically a luxurious hot chocolate, with added health benefits. The powder also contains magnesium, natural vitamin C derived from the acerola fruit, passionflower, lemon balm and shiitake mushroom. Each nutrient is intended to repair your body while you sleep, strengthening bones, muscles, joints and skin.

However, if you’re expecting a super sweet chocolatey drink, this isn’t it. It tastes slightly bitter but very authentic with its natural cocoa flavour and doesn’t contain any of the sugars, additives or preservatives you’ll find in supermarket hot chocolate.

We mixed ours with hot oat milk and drank a cup every night before bed. The combination of the magnesium with the cocoa and warm milk was incredibly soothing and we felt ready for sleep as soon as we’d finished the drink. Our sleep tracking app also showed that we’d slept through the night without waking up, which was a win.

Back to top

Blooming Blends nighttime tincture

Blooming blends nighttime tincture
  • Best: For feeling calm before bed
  • Volume: 30ml
  • How to take it: Place a full pipette under your tongue
  • Why we love it
    • Great alternative to tablets
    • Helped with relaxation
  • Take note
    • Didn’t notice a huge change in sleep quality

If you’re looking for a quick fix without having to make a whole sleep drink, this tincture from Blooming blends could be it. Ideal for anyone who doesn’t enjoy swallowing pills, tinctures are liquid supplements that you place under your tongue with a dropper.

This tincture contains chamomile, lavender, limeflower and ashwagandha root, which is known for its natural relaxant properties and ability to soothe stress and anxiety. The liquid also contains oat straw, derived from the unripened Avena sativa plant which is typically used to reduce inflammation and improve brain function and mood.

We took a full pipette of the tincture each night before sleep, letting the liquid sit under my tongue before swallowing it. The overall effect was one of relaxation, however, we didn’t drop off as quickly as we have with some other supplements. Nonetheless, we felt very chilled and found our mind felt calmer, despite a busy day. Our sleep didn’t really change but we did find that we woke up feeling relaxed and not at all anxious too.

Back to top

Ten Pm The night drink

tenpm the night drink
  • Best: For flavour
  • Volume: 300g
  • How to take: Mix two teaspoons with 200ml of water or your milk of choice
  • Why we love it
    • Added L-glycine, zinc and B6
    • Delicious flavour
  • Take note
    • Added sweetener

A much milder chocolatey drink than the Welleco evening elixir, the night drink by Ten PM is a win for anyone who dislikes a strong bitter cocoa flavour. More akin to a smooth hot chocolate, this drinkable supplement contains organic cacao, 3,000mg of L-glycine to support mood and hormonal regulation and 125mg of magnesium citrate to relax and repair the body.

This powder also contains passionflower, zinc, vitamin B6 and L-theanine. It’s sweetened with stevia and xanthan so while there’s a sweeter flavour (one serving is 23 calories), if you’re trying to avoid sweeteners this might not be the pick for you.

We mixed it with foamed oat milk and found it very easy to drink. The addition of L-glycine impressed us as we’ve been trying to incorporate it into my wellness routine lately. We found that we felt relaxed before bed and slept deeply, however, we did wake up a couple of times. This might have been due to the slightly lower levels of magnesium present and our sleep therefore being lighter, or it might have been because the bin men were making more noise than usual – these variables are tricky to track. Either way, we were impressed with the powder and it tasted great.

  1.  £35 from Tenpm.co
Prices may vary
Back to top

Phyto Nectars I am rested

phyto nectars I am rested sleep drink
  • Best: Fruit-flavoured sleep drink
  • Volume: 5 x 10g Sachets
  • How to take it: Mix with warm milk of your choice
  • Why we love it
    • Great for people who don’t enjoy chocolate drinks
    • Pre-measured sachets
    • Contains super mushrooms

Mushrooms are all the rage at the moment – and these supplement drinks from Phyto nectars harness the power of the shroom. If a chocolate drink at bedtime isn’t your thing, these sachets are made with reishi and lion’s mane as well as blueberries and guava which give the drink a deep purple colour.

Containing magnesium, lavender, passionflower and L-theanine to support restful sleep, each sachet contains oat beta-glucan extract and holy basil – a herb used for stress relief.

We got on really well with these sachets. They’re pre-measured so they’re easy to pop in a cup and enjoy each evening. I added hot oat milk to mine but I also tried them with coconut milk, which was delicious. The flavour is fruity and a little earthy and I found that I fell asleep quickly and logged more deep sleep on my tracker.”

Back to top

The verdict: Sleep supplements

For the best sleep supplement that will help you rest easy, turn to the PM+ complex by JSHealth. We found it the best for falling asleep quickly and promoting deep undisturbed sleep. If you struggle to swallow pills and prefer to take your supplement in liquid form, your best bet is the Blooming Blends nighttime tincture. But if flavour is your main concern, you can’t go wrong with a rich low-calorie bedtime brew from Welleco. However, if hot chocolate isn’t your jam, try a fruity “phyto latte” with added super mushrooms from Phyto Nectars instead.

Read more: Tribulus supplements can help boost libido – but are they for everyone?

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in