Saudi Arabia has started spreading its own ‘fake news’ in the latest bizarre turn in its row with Qatar

Not only are Saudi news outlets releasing threatening videos and encouraging dissent against Qatar’s ruler, but they are also claiming Western media is ‘misleadingly’ reporting on what’s happening

Anthony Harwood
Wednesday 23 August 2017 09:51 EDT
Comments
A Qatari passenger is going to be no less terrified that the pilot might lose his bearings just because the Qatar Airways logo has been removed in the second half of a video sequence
A Qatari passenger is going to be no less terrified that the pilot might lose his bearings just because the Qatar Airways logo has been removed in the second half of a video sequence (AFP/Getty)

Your support helps us to tell the story

From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.

At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.

The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.

Your support makes all the difference.

When it takes Julian Assange, of all people, to point out how Saudi Arabia’s dirty tricks campaign has gone into overdrive, you know it’s reaching Alice in Wonderland proportions.

From his bolthole in the Ecuadorian embassy, the Wikileaks founder took to Twitter to complain that the Saudi-owned TV station Al Arabiya was making “increasingly absurd fabrications” in the country’s 11-week-long dispute with Qatar.

In particular he took the broadcaster to task for quoting him saying Qatar had paid ”huge sums of money” for two damaging cables not to be published.

Equally absurd was the Arab TV station’s attack on The Independent and Newsweek over the weekend.

Both had reported widespread outrage at an animated Al Arabiya video showing a Qatar Airways passenger plane being shot down by a Saudi jet for straying into the desert kingdom’s airspace.

Saudi Arabia closed its borders to Qatar at the start of June when it launched a diplomatic and transport blockade of the country over its supposed support for extremism and cosying up to Iran, which the tiny Gulf state denies.

The video led to a complaint by Qatar to the International Civil Aviation Organisation that the Saudis were “terrorising” travellers.

Trump and Polish president Duda connect over disapproval for 'fake news'

But in an extreme case of splitting hairs, Al Arabiya then launched a bizarre attack claiming the “Western media outlets” had “misleadingly” reported what the footage conveyed.

It said the video began with a Saudi jet forcing a passenger jet – with the Qatar Airways logo on the side – to land for entering its airspace.

This was followed by a second sequence in which a missile is fired at the aircraft in midair. But on this occasion the plane’s Qatar Airways logo had been removed – so, they tried to claim, it wasn’t a Qatari plane.

I think not. It’s the same animated video sequence; it’s the same voiceover talking about what Saudi Arabia can do under international law if a Qatari plane strays into its airspace; it’s the same aeroplane, bar a logo.

If it walks like a duck, swims like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it’s probably a duck.

Plus, who else has Saudi Arabia closed its border to?

A Qatari passenger is going to be no less terrified that the pilot might lose his bearings just because the Qatar Airways logo has been removed in the second half of a video sequence.

As well as singling out The Independent for its coverage, the Al Arabiya report also named the Newsweek journalist involved in writing up the story for his own outlet, noting that “he has frequently been featured on Al Jazeera Arabic, the news channel that has led a campaign against the Arab countries boycotting Qatar”. How dare he!

That’s the same Al Jazeera TV station that, in their ludicrous list of 13 demands at the outset of the dispute, the Saudi-led alliance said should be closed down.

OK, as the Qataris said at the time, you close down Al Arabiya, and we’ll close Al Jazeera.

But while Al Jazeera is an internationally respected news organisation, Al Arabiya, in Assange’s words, is just becoming, well, absurd.

Consider how gleefully it seized upon this week’s story of how a little-known cousin of the Emir of Qatar was paraded around Saudi Arabia and touted as a mediator between the two countries.

Not only did he get to see the Crown Prince, but he was also flown to Morocco to meet King Salman himself at his holiday retreat.

Sheikh Abdullah bin Ali al-Thani, who’s an elderly relative of the current Emir living in Saudi and married to a Saudi woman, in a matter of hours become the proud owner of a Twitter account with 250,000 followers.

It is being deluged with people calling for the ruling Emir of Qatar, Sheikh Tamim, to step down, using a hashtag which reads (in translation) “Abdullah is Qatar’s Future”.

It’s too laughable to be a serious attempt to overthrow the ruling family of Qatar. But a report by Al Arabiya goes so far as to run a photograph of the pretender with the caption: “Sheikh Abdullah Althani the wise, ‘the light at the end of the tunnel’.”

It dresses up the story to be about how Abdullah has mediated between the two countries to facilitate Qataris travelling to this month’s Hajj in Saudi Arabia, the pilgrimage to Mecca every Muslim must do once in their life if they are able. But it’s actually just a rather clumsy call to the people of Qatar to ditch their ruler.

The reality is that Sheikh Tamim’s popularity has soared ever since he stood up to Saudi-led aggression at the start of June, which the Che Guevera-style images of him displayed on buildings and social media show.

As the Al Bawaba website, based in Jordan but with offices across the Arab world, put it: “Fake News Gulf Crisis Style: No, Al Arabiya, Qataris Are Not Begging Their Emir To Step Down”.

In its report, Al Bawaba noted: “On closer inspection the embedded tweets in Al Arabiya appear to come from Saudi accounts… in fact a quick search of the ‘Leave Tamin’ hashtag quickly reveals Qataris flooding Twitter instead with derision towards the hashtag, and support for their Emir.”

Absurd, indeed.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in