Hartley hooks a starting berth
Northampton No 2 goes head to head against master scrummagers Argentina
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Three changes to the spine of the team – at scrum-half, hooker and No 8 – plus an enforced switch in the crucial position of tight-head prop? Martin Johnson, who might consider himself beleaguered but for the unprecedented pledges of job security offered him by his employers at the Rugby Football Union, would hardly claim this to be ideal preparation for a Test match against a team as dangerous as Argentina, who pitch up at Twickenham this weekend.
As expected, the Paris-based James Haskell, subject of the manager's ire when he first moved across the water, will fill the back-row hole created by the abrupt demotion of Jordan Crane. It was also obvious that Duncan Bell would replace his injured Bath clubmate, David Wilson, in the prop department. However, there were never any guarantees that Dylan Hartley and Paul Hodgson would get the nod ahead of Steve Thompson and Danny Care at Nos 2 and 9 respectively.
These are choices driven by the events of last weekend, when England slipped off acceptable standards against Australia. "We want Paul to bring his maturity and leadership to the mix," Johnson said. "As for Dylan, he missed a lot of the training in the run-up to the Australia match and while he was fit to start on the day, we felt it sensible to play the guy who'd done all the preparation. This time, Dylan has been fully involved right the way through."
For the 35-year-old Bell, this opportunity is heaven-sent. "I spent 18 months out of the game after my one and only previous start for England in 2005, struggling with a career-threatening knee injury," he said. "Without wishing to sound melodramatic, I've treasured every game for Bath since then. I'm fully aware of my age, and of the injuries to others that have put me in this position, but I'm here to take advantage of the situation. Had I been forced to retire with just two caps to my name, I'd have been bitterly frustrated. Now, I have another chance."
Bell has been playing serious professional rugby for well over a decade. At the other end of the experience spectrum stands Paul Doran-Jones, summoned out of the blue last weekend as propping cover against a side equipped with the most fearsome scrummage in the world game.
An old schoolmate and close friend of Haskell – the two were implicated in the production of an extremely dodgy video while studying at Wellington College – the 24-year-old Gloucester forward was admirably relaxed as he fielded the inevitable questions on the subject yesterday. "It was a mistake, made a long time ago," he said. "I hope my rugby will be the focus now."
Under the circumstances, he could have done without Johnson reporting that he'd "had a bit of a bang". Happily, the manager was referring to a training-ground knock that would not threaten Doran-Jones' participation this weekend.
England v Argentina: Teams for Saturday
England
U Monye (Quins) 15
M Cueto (Sale) 14
D Hipkiss (Leicester) 13
S Geraghty (N'ton) 12
M Banahan (Bath) 11
J Wilkinson (Toulon) 10
P Hodgson (L Irish) 9
T Payne (Wasps) 1
D Hartley (N'ton) 2
D Bell (Bath) 3
L Deacon (Leicester) 4
S Borthwick (Saracens, capt) 5
T Croft (Leicester) 6
L Moody (Leicester) 7
J Haskell (Stade F) 8
Replacements: 16 S Thompson (Brive) 17 P Doran-Jones (Glouc) 18 C Lawes (N'ton) 19 J Worsley (Wasps) 20 D Care (Quins) 21 A Goode (Brive) 22 A Erinle (Biarritz)
Argentina
H Agulla (Brive) 15
L Borges (Albi) 14
G Tiesi (Quins) 13
M Rodriguez (Rosa) 12
M Comuzzi (Pucara) 11
S Fernandez (Hindu) 10
A Lalanne (L Irish) 9
R Roncero (Stade F) 1
M Ledesma (Clerm A) 2
M Scelzo (Clerm A) 3
E Lozada (Toulon) 4
P Albacete (Toulouse) 5
T Leonardi (SIC) 6
A Abadie (Rovigo) 7
J M F Lobbe (Toulon) 8
Replacements: 16 A V Basualdo (Toulouse) 17 M Ayerza (Leicester) 18 M Carizza (Biarritz) 19 A Campos (Montauban) 20 A Figuerola (CASI) 21 B Urdapilleta (CUBA) 22 F M Aramburu (Dax)
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments