Football: Soul of Europe's spectacle in peril
Champions' League: Unwanted guests at the feast take their turn in a competition under threat of extinction
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.IN THE 1950s it brought Di Stefano and Puskas, bewitching figures in white. In the 1960s there were the Lisbon Lions and Best and Charlton's joyous epitaph to the Munich disaster. The 70s, Cruyff and Beckenbauer, Liverpool and Forest, were followed by the 80s horror of Heysel. Redemption came with a Dutch flourish at Milan and Ajax.
It is this heritage, both glorious and tragic, that has made the European Cup the most prestigious club competition in the world. But everything has a price and, as the game hurtles towards the millennium on the accelerator of television's riches, the competition's soul is about to be sold.
Tonight, at a dozen stadiums from Porto to Athens, the European Cup, its classic format already bastardised and bloated, will begin its last stand.
At Old Trafford it will do so with pride as Manchester United and Barcelona, two of the competition's giants, do battle. In Austria it will do so shame- facedly. It is bad enough hosting a game in the 14,000-capacity Arnold Schwarzenegger-Stadion, what really embarrasses the Champions' League is that Sturm Graz and Spartak Moscow are unwanted guests at the feast.
Outside of their own borders the results of neither team would warrant a second glance. Yet they are involved in the sport's richest club competition while Milan, Paris St-Germain, Liverpool, Borussia Dortmund and Marseilles are not.
Those five clubs have been approached to join the European super league proposed by the Milan-based company, Media Partners. All have a greater claim through achievement, resources and prestige to be part of such a league than Graz or Spartak but, unlike those two, they all failed to win a place on merit.
It is hard enough already for the unfashionable and unwanted. Of the first wave of championship winners Uefa sent over the top back in July only two, HJK Helsinki and Dynamo Kiev, have survived to this stage. They join seven other champions, and seven clubs who were runners-up last year - including Manchester United, Internazionale and Bayern Munich.
It would be churlish to deny that these appear bigger draws than the likes of Litex Lovech or Skonto Riga, to name two of the champions who perished in the qualifiers. It is a fair assumption that, if the aim is to find the best team in Europe, it is more likely to be found in Italy than Estonia. Why then, should Italy not have more representatives? Such a view does fit in with the competition's original conception.
Provoked by the claim of Stan Cullis, the manager of Wolverhampton Wanderers, that his club were the best in Europe Gabriel Hanot, the editor of the French sports newspaper L'Equipe, invited the representatives of leading European clubs to a meeting. They were chosen on reputation, not because they were champions.
The following season - 1955-56 - 16 clubs staged the first competition, including Hibernian who had come only fifth in the Scottish League. Of that 16 only Real Madrid and PSV Eindhoven will be playing in the Champions' League tonight. Milan, Sporting Lisbon and Anderlecht may come under consideration for a super league but most of the others - such as Stade Reims, Rot-Weiss Essen, Saarbrucken and Hibs - have long since declined.
Defeating the transitory nature of success - and even Manchester United and Milan have been in their respective second divisions - is what the super league is all about. For newcomers to the party, like Kaiserslautern, Lens and Athletic Bilbao, this is the season to impress: they might be asked to stay.
But by whom? Media Partners or Uefa? The latter, football's European governing body, took over the competition in its second year and kept control until now, gradually giving concessions to the bigger clubs, most notably when they created the Champions' League format in 1992 and then extended it to runners-up last season. Both steps have been financially successful but, instead of sating the big clubs, the adjustments have merely increased their desire for a bigger share of the cake.
Uefa's leaders are now split between appeasing the big clubs and countries, which generate the wealth, and assisting the smaller ones who, in the corridors of Uefa and world body Fifa power, cumulatively have more votes.
Compromise is in the offing. Uefa is desperate to retain control of the European game and few clubs wish to step outside it. Meanwhile the weaker nations are painfully aware that crumbs from the rich man's table are better than nothing. Uefa met representatives of the major leagues on Monday and will do so again in four weeks' time. In the meantime it seeks a solution which would retain the integrity of domestic leagues, allow the biggest clubs the certainty of more matches against each other while retaining the possibility that the smaller ones may play them occasionally.
This is likely to be a European league consisting of the champions of the biggest countries, a token qualifier or two, and a select group of elite teams chosen by a carefully constructed, ever-flexible, formula.
For English clubs, struggling to combine Europe with a demanding domestic league, this competition would be even harder to win. The alternative - to effectively build two squads - is at present beyond all but United, and it would not be easy for them. From Murdoch's Theatre of Dreams to Arnie's Austrian hideaway this, then, is the season to create a new European legend.
GROUP A
PORTO
OLYMPIAKOS
CROATIA ZAGREB
AJAX
Tonight
Porto v Olympiakos
Croatia Zagreb v Ajax
30 September
Ajax v Porto
Olympiakos v Croatia Zagreb
21 October
Olympiakos v Ajax
Porto v Croatia Zagreb
4 November
Ajax v Olympiakos
Croatia Zagreb v Porto
25 November
Olympiakos v Porto
Ajax v Croatia Zagreb
9 December
Porto v Ajax
Croatia Zagreb v Olympiakos
ATHLETIC BILBAO
ROSENBORG TRONDHEIM
JUVENTUS
GALATASARAY
Tonight
Athletic Bilbao v Rosenborg Trondheim
Juventus v Galatasaray
30 September
Galatasaray v Athletic Bilbao
Rosenborg Trondheim v Juventus
21 October
Rosenborg Trondheim v Galatasaray
Athletic Bilbao v Juventus
4 November
Galatasaray v Rosenborg Trondheim
Juventus v Athletic Bilbao
25 November
Rosenborg Trondheim v Athletic Bilbao
Galatasaray v Juventus
9 December
Athletic Bilbao v Galatasaray
Juventus v Rosenborg Trondheim
REAL MADRID
INTERNAZIONALE
STURM GRAZ
SPARTAK MOSCOW
Tonight
Real Madrid v Internazionale
Sturm Graz v Spartak Moscow
30 September
Spartak Moscow v Real Madrid
Internazionale v Sturm Graz
21 October
Internazionale v Spartak Moscow
Real Madrid v Sturm Graz
4 November
Spartak Moscow v Internazionale
Sturm Graz v Real Madrid
25 November
Internazionale v Real Madrid
Spartak Moscow v Sturm Graz
9 December
Real Madrid v Spartak Moscow
Sturm Graz v Internazionale
BRONDBY
BAYERN MUNICH
MANCHESTER UTD
BARCELONA
Tonight
Brondby v Bayern Munich
Manchester Utd v Barcelona
30 September
Barcelona v Brondby
Bayern Munich v Manchester Utd
21 October
Bayern Munich v Barcelona
Brondby v Manchester Utd
4 November
Barcelona v Bayern Munich
Manchester Utd v Brondby
25 November
Bayern Munich v Brondby
Barcelona v Manchester Utd
9 December
Brondby v Barcelona
Manchester Utd v Bayern Munich
LENS
ARSENAL
PANATHINAIKOS
DYNAMO KIEV
Tonight
Lens v Arsenal
Panathinaikos v Dynamo Kiev
30 September
Dynamo Kiev v Lens
Arsenal v Panathinaikos
21 October
Arsenal v Dynamo Kiev
Lens v Panathinaikos
4 November
Dynamo Kiev v Arsenal
Panathinaikos v Lens
25 November
Arsenal v Lens
Dynamo Kiev v Panathinaikos
9 December
Lens v Dynamo Kiev
Panathinaikos v Arsenal
PSV EINDHOVEN
HJK HELSINKI
KAISERSLAUTERN
BENFICA
Tonight
PSV Eindhoven v HJK Helsinki
Kaiserslautern v Benfica
30 September
Benfica v PSV Eindhoven
HJK Helsinki v Kaiserslautern
21 October
HJK Helsinki v Benfica
PSV Eindhoven v Kaiserslautern
4 November
Benfica v HJK Helsinki
Kaiserslautern v PSV Eindhoven
25 November
HJK Helsinki v PSV Eindhoven
Benfica v Kaiserslautern
9 December
PSV Eindhoven v Benfica
Kaiserslautern v HJK Helsinki Group winners plus two best second-placed teams qualify for quarter-finals. Should two clubs finish equal on points after the six group matches, the following criteria will be applied to determine placings: 1 Greater number of points obtained in matches between the clubs in question. 2 Goal difference resulting from the matches between the clubs in question. 3 Greater number of goals scored away from home in matches between the clubs in question. 4 Superior goal difference from all matches played. 5 Greater number of goals scored. 6 National association's co-efficient at start of season. The two best runners-up will be decided by the following criteria: 1 Number of points obtained in group matches. 2 Goal difference from all group matches. 3 Greater number of goals scored in all gro up matches. 4 Greater number of goals scored away from home. 5 National association's co-efficient at start of season. 6 Individual club co-efficient at the start of season.
Quarter-finals: March 3 and 17, 1999. Semi-finals: April 7 and 21. Final: May 26.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments