‘Staff knew disabled residents at HSE-run facility were being sexually abused’
The National Independent Review Panel’s ‘Brandon’ report found a lack of external oversight allowed the situation at the centre to worsen over time.
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Adults with learning difficulties were subjected to sustained sexual abuse by another resident at an HSE-run facility with the full knowledge of staff and management, a report has found.
The National Independent Review Panel found that a lack of external management oversight and leadership from the Health Service Executive allowed the abuse at the centre in Co Donegal to worsen over time.
Known as the “Brandon” report, an executive summary published on Thursday revealed that staff felt “powerless” as they regularly reported incidents to the director of nursing at the time.
Staff made the reports with the expectation that something would change, but it never did, the report said.
Evidence available on file would suggest that Brandon regularly targeted particular individuals and was able to identify particularly vulnerable residents whom he pursued relentlessly
The review examined a number of serious incidents involving a resident known as “Brandon” at the facility at St Joseph’s Community Hospital in Stranorlar.
It identified 18 residents who were sexually assaulted in incidents that occurred between 2003 and 2016.
However, the report said the first recorded incident of sexual assault by Brandon was January 28 1997, when he was found by staff to have his hands on the genitals of another resident.
A further three incidents of inappropriate sexual behaviour were noted from 1997 to December 2002.
The report said these earlier records suggest that managers knew about the sexual assaults before 2003.
From 2003 onwards the number of incidents involving sexually inappropriate behaviour by Brandon increased, the report added.
The first recorded incident addressed by the review occurred on January 16 2003 when Brandon was observed to be touching another resident “inappropriately”.
Between then and 2011 he engaged in a “vast number of highly abusive and sexually intrusive behaviours”.
“Evidence available on file would suggest that Brandon regularly targeted particular individuals and was able to identify particularly vulnerable residents whom he pursued relentlessly,” the report stated.
The review found that a “common management strategy” to deal with Brandon’s behaviour was to move him around various wards. He was moved a total of nine times in the 15-year period covered by the review.
“While each of these moves provided some respite to the staff and residents from the ward Brandon was vacating, unfortunately they also gave him access to other residents, many of whom became new victims of his abusive behaviour,” the report stated.
On December 22 2011 Brandon was moved to House Two, in the Stillwater complex, to live by himself away from other vulnerable residents.
“While this move resulted in a sharp reduction in the number of sexual assaults recorded, unfortunately, on September 5 2013, he was moved back again to House One to live with the residents he had previously assaulted,” the report said.
So on behalf of the HSE, I do want to apologise, sincerely apologise
“Brandon’s move to House Two appears to be the only successful strategy employed in the management of Brandon in that it did provide some protection, albeit short term, to other residents.”
On Thursday, HSE chief executive Paul Reid apologised to residents and their families.
“The facts are very clear. Vulnerable people were sexually abused whilst in our care. None of us can imagine the impact this has had on the abused and indeed on their families,” he said.
“So on behalf of the HSE, I do want to apologise, sincerely apologise. For those residents and their families, I just can’t imagine and we can’t imagine the hurt they have had and the pain in receiving the details of this report. We are really truly sorry.”
Mr Reid described the report as “one of the most repulsive reports that I’ve read and one of the most gruesome reports I’ve had to read in my career”.
He promised that the HSE would embrace and implement all the findings in the report.
“I would say to anyone working in this area, or indeed any families, please do speak up if you have concerns,” he said at a HSE briefing on Covid-19.
The HSE fully accepts the findings of the National Independent Review Panel
In a statement earlier, the HSE apologised “for the failings in care”.
“The HSE fully accepts the findings of the National Independent Review Panel (the ‘Brandon’ report),” it said in a statement.
“The HSE received the initial report in August 2020 by which time Brandon was no longer residing in the service.
“On receipt of the report, the HSE acted immediately to seek assurance as to the current safety of the residents within the relevant service.
“The HSE’s primary concern is the current safety of residents.”