Melania Trump: How have other first ladies coped with the pressures of the international spotlight?
President's wife under fire for wearing coat featuring insensitive slogan but there are few set guidelines for how a FLOTUS should behave
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Melania Trump is under fire for her decision to wear an army green coat with “I really don’t care, do u?” emblazoned on the back during a visit to a Texas detention centre.
The US first lady has been widely criticised for the insensitivity of the gesture, made during a visit to a child migrant shelter on the US-Mexico border in the wake of her husband being pressured to sign an executive order cancelling the separation of children from their families as part of a “zero tolerance” crackdown on illegal immigration.
Spokeswoman Stephanie Grisham told reporters there was “no hidden message” behind the selection of the jacket, which is sold by high street retailer Zara for $39 (£29).
But Donald Trump immediately contradicted this stance on Twitter, suggesting the coat was an expression of his wife’s disgust at the “Fake News Media”.
Ms Trump has been the subject of much scrutiny in recent weeks over her absence from public life.
Last month she underwent a kidney operation but has since appeared reluctant to attend functions and been seldom seen, eventually issuing a tweet to address press speculation about her whereabouts.
“Rest assured, I’m here at the White House w my family, feeling great, & working hard on behalf of children & the American people!” she wrote.
Following her husband’s inauguration in January last year, Ms Trump preferred to stay in New York City for several months rather than join him living in Washington, DC, stating a desire to shield their son Barron – then 10 – from the media’s glare.
She has cut a reserved figure ever since, preferring to work quietly on her anti-bullying agenda – the subject of much satire because of her husband’s aggressive approach to going about his business.
When she has played the hostess, many of Melania’s efforts have passed off without a hitch but she has often been mocked: notably over accusations her cyberbullying pamphlet was no more than a reprint of an Obama-era forerunner with a new cover and for her “creepy” Christmas decorations.
An unintentionally surreal oak tree-planting photo op on the White House lawn with France’s Emmanuel and Brigitte Macron this spring was also the subject of much ridicule.
For her part, Ms Macron told Le Monde she found Melania to be “very fun” in private but so hamstrung in her behaviour as a result of the scrutiny she is under “she can’t even open a window”.
Melania’s frequent habit of batting away her husband’s hand whenever he attempts to hold her’s on official visits has meanwhile led to whispering that their marriage is an unhappy one.
The responsibilities of a first lady are only loosely defined and how the current incumbent enacts it depends very much on their personality.
Operating with their own White House staff, first ladies can take a prominent political campaigning role, champion specific social causes they feel passionate about or play a ceremonial part on occasions of state.
While Ms Trump’s predecessor, Michelle Obama, was a tireless presence in Washington, the wives of presidents George HW Bush and his son George W Bush, Barbara and Laura Bush, both preferred to focus on their pet causes: literacy and women’s rights.
Other notable campaigns include Lady Bird Johnson pursuing environmental pollution, Pat Nixon promoting volunteerism, Nancy Reagan’s foray into the war on drugs and Hillary Clinton’s ambitions for healthcare reform.
Dolley Madison (1768-1849), wife of the fourth president James Madison, is credited with setting the template for first ladies to follow by furnishing the White House, working to help orphans and women and attracting press interest due to her modish manner of dress. She was given an honorary seat on the floor of Congress and her popularity contributed enormously to her husband’s appeal.
Her example is said to have abided until Eleanor Roosevelt’s tenure, barring the extraordinary case of Edith Wilson, forced to run the executive branch of government between October 1919 and March 1921 after her husband, president Woodrow Wilson, suffered a debilitating stroke and was left bedridden. Nancy Reagan is also said to have come to husband Ronald’s aid on multiple occasions when his health was failing.
Ms Roosevelt, serving as first lady between 1933 and 1945, redefined the role entirely thanks to her outspoken character.
Ahead of her time in her attitudes to race and gender, Eleanor Roosevelt held regular press conferences, wrote regular newspaper and magazine columns, hosted a radio show, spoke at party conventions and was never afraid to publicly disagree with her husband’s policy agenda.
The pressure for first ladies to be picture-perfect matriarchs perhaps stems from the impossibly high standards of glamour Jacqueline Kennedy set in the early 1960s.
This superficial sheen of perfection is hard to maintain and the extraordinary pressure and scrutiny the presidency attracts can inevitably take a toll on a marriage.
The humiliation Hillary Clinton suffered when news of her husband Bill’s affair with intern Monica Lewinsky broke in 1997 was made doubly hard to bear because the eyes of the world were watching.
Jackie Kennedy likewise had to make peace with her husband’s philandering but was spared the same degree of lurid outside interest.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments