18 years ago, Brian Shaffer walked into a bar and was never seen again. Now Ohio brothers are suing a Redditor who accused them of his murder
Did the death of Brian’s mother and stress of medical school cause him to run away from his life? Kill himself? Or is he still alive? If so, where could he be? Andrea Cavallier reports on one of Ohio’s mysterious missing person cases
The latest headlines from our reporters across the US sent straight to your inbox each weekday
Your briefing on the latest headlines from across the US
Your briefing on the latest headlines from across the US
A medical student walked into a bar near the Ohio State campus in the early morning hours of April 1, 2006 – and vanished.
It may sound like an April Fool’s prank, but it’s one of Ohio’s biggest mysteries.
Brian Shaffer was 27 years old when he strolled into The Ugly Tuna Saloona, a local college bar lit up by a bright neon sign that read “Fresh Fish. Ugly Owners.”
Surveillance footage from outside the establishment captured the med student entering the bar around 1:55am. Then, he was gone.
For nearly two decades, Brian’s disappearance has been a mystery to Ohio residents.
Online sleuths tossed around theories of what happened to Brian, delving deep into cold case subreddits, hoping to crack the case, particularly on Reddit, a social media platform that allows users to post and interact anonymously.
Did he drunkenly stumble odd and down in the Olentangy River? Or, because there was no surveillance footage of him leaving the bar, is he still there, his body hidden in the walls, or a beer keg?
In one “Brian Shaffer” subreddit, a user with the handle “QueeenBeeeee” frequently posted about the case, among others, repeatedly mentioning the names of a pair of brothers from Ohio, alleging that they were ones responsible.
Now, those brothers are suing the unknown user referred to as “Jane Doe,” in the lawsuit, for defamation.
A reddit user accused them of murder. Now, they’re suing
Matthew Osowski and Brian Osowski filed a lawsuit in the Franklin County Common Pleas Court this week against anonymous Reddit user “QueeenBeeeee.
The lawsuit alleges that the Reddit user, listed as “Jane Doe,” continuously accused them in the comments of being involved in multiple homicide and missing person cases, including Brian Shaffer’s case.
In the Brian Shaffer subreddit, the QueeenBeeeee user shared their theories about the case alongside accusations that the Osowski brothers are “psychopath serial killers,” according to a post viewed by The Columbus Dispatch.
Other posts included personal information about the brothers, including what they look like, where they live, and where they work. There is no evidence to connect the Osowski brothers to Brain’s disappearance, or any other case and the posts have since been deleted by Reddit.
According to the lawsuit, the user also alleges that the brothers were involved in the 2005 murder of 20-year-old Julie Popovich, and the disappearances of Tyler Davis and Joey LaBute. However, again, there is no indication the brothers had anything to do with these cases. In fact, in 2007, Adam Saleh was convicted of Popovich’s death and is currently serving a life sentence.
The Osowski brothers are seeking $25,000 in monetary damages, according to the lawsuit. They are also requesting retractions of the postings, as well as a court order stopping QueeenBeeeee from posting any more allegations. The account has since been suspended.
In a statement provided to The Dispatch on Monday, the attorneys for the brothers said they have no idea who the anonymous poster is and that the lawsuit was filed to put a stop to “this false and unscrupulous behavior.”
“They had no involvement with any of the crimes mentioned in this person’s posts. They had no contact with the victims of the crimes,” the attorney said in the statement.
“The Osowskis have families and jobs and the wild, unsupportable allegations in the postings are irresponsible. The Osowskis are pursuing the matter legally to put a stop to this false and unscrupulous behavior.”
What happened to Brian Shaffer?
Four weeks before Brian Shaffer vanished, his mother, Renee, died of myelodysplasia, a rare form of cancer.
In the days and weeks that followed, Brian, his brother Derek Shaffer, and their father, Randall “Randy” Shaffer, leaned on each other for support.
Brian began to look to the future, particularly to an upcoming vacation to Miami with his girlfriend, Alexis.
Brian planned to propose on the trip, but he never made his flight.
On March 31, 2006, a Saturday night, Brian joined his friend William “Clint” Florence for a bar crawl near the Ohio State campus.
They stopped at Ugly Tuna Saloona in Columbus’ University District, but then left heading towards the Arena District and Short North.
Later in the night, another friend, Meredith Reed, offered the two of them a ride back to Ugly Tuna, and they returned to the bar.
Surveillance camera footage shows Brian and his friends at the bar’s entrance around 1:15 a.m. He was last seen chatting with two women and walking back inside the bar before he disappeared.
His friends tried to call him after they lost each other in the bar but only got his voicemail. Figuring he went home, they left.
When Brian did not show up for his flight on Monday, his father grew worried and reported him missing.
Last video footage of Brian
Brian’s father searched his apartment but found everything where it was supposed to be.
His bed was made and his medical books were neatly positioned on the shelves.
A search was launched, as cadaver dogs canvassed the area around the bar, the woods near the river and the campgrounds.
Surveillance footage that captured Brian’s last movements was reviewed over and over, but police still had no answers.
In the video, Brian, Clint and Meredith rode the escalator to the bar at 1:15 a.m. An hour later, Clint and Meredith came back down. But Brian wasn’t with them.
“The police were just as confused as the rest of us,” Derek Shaffer told a local news outlet. “They did everything they could to try and find my brother.”
Clint and Meredith were questioned by the police. She passed a polygraph, but Clint allegedly refused to take one, it was reported.
Weeks passed, then months, but Brian’s family refused to give up hope. His father Randy conducted media interviews, created a website for tips from the public and kept praying that his son would be found.
Then the wild theories and hoax tips began to trickle in.
Someone called Jesus claimed that Brian was beaten unconscious by two men after a clash at the Ugly Tuna.
“[Jesus said] ‘When Brian woke up, he had a big black penis in his mouth,’” Mr Shaffer recalled in 2007. “[He said] they shot him in the head, burned his body and had sex with his ashes.”
But it wasn’t a tip, it was a hoax.
There were alleged sightings of Brian in Atlanta and Sweden. But nothing led to finding him.
His brother Derek told The Dispatch that he stays away from what people say about Brian online.
“I don’t really read stuff about Brian online,” Derek said. “He was going to do great things as a doctor. He wasn’t into drugs or anything like that. I don’t think he would just take off and never contact us again. No, he wouldn’t have done that to us.”
“I’m afraid that something bad did happen, and we may never find out,” he added.
Another tragic loss
In 2008, two years after Brian went missing, the Shaffer family suffered another tragic loss.
Brian’s father, Randall “Randy” Shaffer, 55, died in a windstorm that pummeled central Ohio, killing at least six people in the area.
Mr Shaffer was believed to have been walking to a shed in the backyard of his Fairfield County home during the storm when he was struck and killed by a falling limb, Fairfield County Sheriff Dave Phalen said at the time, according to The Columbus Dispatch.
When he didn’t show up for his job with Midway Electric, where he worked as an electrician, neighbors went to his house and found his body in the backyard.
Mr Shaffer had been a familiar face to many in central Ohio who followed his well-publicized search to find his son.
Within three years, Derek Shaffer had lost his mother, brother, and now his father.
On Brian’s right bicep was a tattoo of the stickman pictured on Pearl Jam’s debut single, “Alive.”
He was a devoted fan and planned to see them in Cincinnati. But he never made it.
Four years after Brian went missing, the group performed “Come Back” at Columbus’ Nationwide Arena, two miles from the Ugly Tuna.
Eddie Vedder, the lead vocalist of the band, dedicated the track to Brian: “Wherever you are, we’re still thinking about you,” he said.