Lost children: The 60 boys and girls who have vanished
One disappears every five minutes. So how many are lost in Britain right now? The scandal is that nobody knows
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.The swing is empty. The roundabout is turning but there is nobody on it. You call out, but there is no reply. You shout louder. Nothing. You scream a name and people turn to stare. They see panic. "Help me," you think, but who can you trust? Who has taken your child? You feel sick, helpless, tiny, unable to move.
Hope flares up - she'll run out from behind that bush, chuckling, and you'll sweep her up in your arms, trembling, weeping into her hair with relief - but then the terrors return. She has been stolen. Abducted. She is being murdered or abused somewhere, right now, while you stand here useless. She is crying out for you - "Mummy! Daddy!" - but you can't hear her. You cannot help her. You cannot save her.
Most people are lucky and their child is found quickly. But for others this awful, paralysing moment when hope and fear fight never ends. It just goes on and on. Avril Clarke is trapped in such agonies right now. Her daughter Sasha McLeish went missing in Luton on 23 June. The 15-year-old visited a fair, then said goodbye to her friends at 10pm before starting to walk home. "It has been a horrible nightmare since that day," says Mrs Clarke. "I can't understand why this has happened."
For the past few days a picture of Sasha's face has been posted on the back of 450 white vans operated by the engineering company Emcor, which has done the same in the United States and has seen 28 children found. This is the first scheme of its kind in Britain. In a month's time another face will take Sasha's place. "You hear the stories," says Terry Whale, chief executive of Emcor UK and a father of two, "and you think, 'What if it was my family?'"
All children who will appear on the vans are listed on a police website, and shown above. Among them is the young, smiling face and infant curls of Alan Davidson, who was three years old when he disappeared. He was playing with his little sister Donna and their Afghan hound Kissie in the front garden of their home in Irvine one spring morning. Gran was watching them, but she turned away for a moment. Just a moment. The dog ran out of the gate into the road and Sandy followed. Donna toddled on behind, or so she has been told. The dog and the girl came back, but Sandy did not. He never came back. That was 30 years ago.
"I rack my brains trying to remember some clue to what happened, but I can't," says Donna. "I was so young. It was so traumatic. My mind has gone blank." She has even been hypnotised in an attempt to dredge up a childhood memory of the incident. "I did see a man, and Sandy going away with him. I came round crying, saying, 'No, no, no!'"
A child goes missing every five minutes, according to one estimate. Others suggest that up to 130,000 disappear every year. Some children are just testing the boundaries. Some are on the run from abuse. Some have been thrown out of their homes. Some have been taken by a father, mother or other family member. Some have just got lost. A few have been taken by a stranger. But the really shocking thing is that nobody knows how many.
The estimates are based on samples. They include boys and girls who run away from home for a night or two, maybe two or three times a year. More than 95 per cent of lost children are found or return within two days, says Inspector Ravi Pillai of the Police National Missing Persons Bureau. But when he is asked how many children are missing right now, at this moment, the inspector shakes his head. "I couldn't tell you."
That seems astonishing. If he doesn't know, then who does? "Nobody." Why not? For a start, local police forces have different methods of recording missing persons. They don't talk to each other easily, which is why the bureau exists. The police national computer says about 5,000 people are missing at any one time, but here's the crunch: there is nobody to say how many of them are children. The information is there on the computer. The police can match a name or description to any other individual quickly, as part of an impressive response to a high-risk disappearance that can include helicopters with heat-seeking equipment and news flashes on local television. But nobody is collating and analysing the data to get an overall picture of how many children go missing, where and why.
"We know there is a real need and we are making that case, but it is also very resource intensive," says Inspector Pillai. "Burglary and murder have a higher priority than us."
Helen Southworth, Labour MP for Warrington South, is among a group of MPs trying to do something about that, by introducing new laws or badgering the Treasury for more money. "There are great things going on in local partnerships between the police, children's services and the voluntary sector," she says, "but they are not being co-ordinated nationally."
The Children's Society has just started working with the Department for Education and Skills to assess how to set up a national network of refuges for children who run away. "There is no safety net for people under 16 if they run," says a spokeswoman. "For a long time, people were blissfully unaware that there were children sleeping on the street at all."
Once a child has been missing for a fortnight (or much sooner if the case is high profile) their details are passed to Inspector Pillai's unit at New Scotland Yard. On his wall there is a picture of an American cop in a hamburger joint leaning over to listen to a mop-headed boy, whose stick and handkerchief suggest he has run away from home. The bureau borrowed an American idea to set up www.missingkids.org.uk, which currently shows 69 faces. Some of them are not reproduced above for legal reasons. The results are remarkable: about 75 per cent of the children whose images appear are "recovered" in one way or another. That could mean a happy reunion with their families. Or it could mean a body has been been found.
"The majority are alive, and we are satisfied we do not need to intervene any further," says Inspector Pillai as we walk down the corridor to meet his colleagues. "What do you expect the bureau to look like?" he asks with a smile, prompting thoughts of rows of gleaming computers staffed by busy workers. "Here we are." The reality is six desks in a corner of a poorly-lit, open-plan room overlooking St James's Park station. Pinned to the wall are the pictures of lost children.
Alan Blackburn has been working here since the bureau opened in 1994. He gives an example of the kind of work they do: "If a person goes missing in Yorkshire and a body is washed up in Kent those two forces will have sent us the details separately, and we can make the match." On his desk are framed photographs of his own children. Does it not affect him, dealing daily with heart-rending details of disappearance? "I try not to think about it, but it did sink in when we met Donna Davidson and other relatives earlier this week at the launch of the van scheme, and they were in tears."
Davinia Darch, the team manager, interrupts. "The thing to remember is that less than 3 per cent of these children have been abducted by strangers. It is much rarer than it can seem." Alan agrees. "That is comforting."
But not for Donna, who grew up seeing posters of her brother all over town. Whenever another child disappeared there would be reporters at the door. The habits formed then have not been broken. "My mum and dad still want to know exactly where I am all the time, even at my age," says the 32-year-old. "I'm like that with my own kids."
Her son Brendan is six and "the spitting image of Sandy". History came horribly close to repeating itself at Easter this year when he was being looked after by a neighbour. They live at Saltcoats, on the Ayrshire coast. "My neighbour turned her back on him for five minutes and he was away. He had a great adventure of it with his friends, down on the beach." Brendan was missing for more than four hours. "It was terrible. I was frantic. The only thing I could think of was, 'I can't tell my mum.' I couldn't put her through that again."
Donna has only recently been able to accept that her brother may be dead. "I think he was abducted. I would like to think he has been brought up as their child and had a good life, but the chances of that are slim, I know."
Donna, a natural sceptic, even contacted a medium whom she heard was involved in the search for Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman, and posted him a cowboy suit her brother once wore. "He told me that he believed Sandy had been murdered within a day of going missing, by a man who had been arrested for doing things to children in the past. He told me I was lucky to get away." Did she believe him? Her voice trembles with the hurt and confusion she still feels after all this time, and which is shared by all those who have lost young boys and girls they loved, out of the blue. Hope and fear are still at war. "I sort of believe him. In a way it is comforting. Not much else is."
Contact the Police National Missing Persons Bureau on 0808 100 8777 or go to www.missingkids.org.uk
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN A CHILD DISAPPEARS
3.30pm Sally, a 12-year-old girl, sets off from school to walk home alone. She is usually prompt. When Sally is 15 minutes late her mother starts ringing round friends to ask if they have seen her.
4.30pm The police are called. Officers take a description from Sally's parents and note the circumstances. They must now decide how serious the risk to Sally is. Is there reason to suspect she has been attacked or abducted?
5pm Sally is believed to be in immediate danger. The police set up a command team and deploy all available resources. This may mean dogs and helicopters searching the route from Sally's school to home.
5.30pm A Child Rescue Alert is put out. Sally's photo and description are circulated to radio and television stations which issue a news flash. This is done only in the most serious and urgent cases.
48 hours later Most vanished children have been found by now. Sally's details go to the Police National Missing Persons Bureau in London, which can match them against any body or child found by another force.
14 days later Sally is now re-garded as a long-term missing person; her picture is posted on a website. It may also appear on Emcor's 450 white vans. There is still hope: 75 per cent of cases put online are resolved. Most are found alive.
MISSING
Zhara Abdi or Ibdi 15
Where Belfast
When 20 June 2005
Joanne Barraclough 15
Where Redhill
When 5 July 2006
Lena Begum 15
Where Hitchin
When 1 August 2003
Ablihon Bennett 14
Where UK
When 1 Sept 2006
Mario Borja-Valencia 9
Where London
When 8 May 2001
Kai Lun Chen 17
Where Smethwick
When 16 Oct 2005
Xiao Yan Cheng 18
Where London
When 30 Sept 2002
Sigourney Chisholm 15
Where Toronto
When 15 May 1993
Sandy Davidson 34
Where Irvine
When 22 April 1976
Milun Dhanjee 12
Where Staithes
When 21 Aug 1999
Luke Durbin 19
Where Woodbridge
When 11 May 2006
Daniel Entwistle 11
Where Gt Yarmouth
When 3 May 2003
Tulay Goren 22
Where London
When 6 Jan 1999
Umurerwa Habimana 15
Where London
When 24 May 2005
Vicky Hamilton 31
Where Bathgate
When 10 Feb 1991
Fatima Hassani 27
Where Manchester
When 11 May 1995
Mohammed Ul Haque 15
Where Edinburgh
When 4 Aug 2006
Muzamil Hussain 4
Where Birmingham
When 21 Feb 2006
Janique Irving 7
Where Manchester
When 2 March 2001
Ashia Jabbi 1
Where Lewisham
When 18 Jan 2006
Temitope Juniade 17
Where Barnsley
When 11 Jan 2006
Djany Kailunda 10
Where London
When 15 June 1999
Donald Lewis 25
Where Pontardawe
When 16 Oct 1998
Lingran Lin 11
Where Hove
When 31 July 2006
Lingshan Lin 15
Where Hove
When 31 July 2006
Yan Lin 18
Where Swansea
When 15 March 2006
Lillian Lyustiger 3
Where London
When 4 Nov 2005
Alla Manakova 16
Where London
When 24 March 2000
Sati Marchant 16
Where High Wycombe
When 15 Dec 2002
Nial Mbarak 8
Where Coventry
When 1 March 2005
Sasha McLeish 15
Where Luton
When 23 June 2006
Garry Michael 15
Where Derby
When 7 Sept 2000
Lisa Michael 12
Where Derby
When 7 Sept 2000
Eyman Nahdy 19
Where Sheffield
When 14 Mar 2003
Ben Needham 17
Where Kos
When 24 July 1991
Damien Nettles 26
Where Gurnard
When 2 Nov 1996
Sadiq Niazi 15
Where Nuneaton
When 23 July 2005
Kenny Ohia 21
Where London
When 8 Sept 1999
Ashley Ojeuderie 6
Where Watford
When 1 Sept 2005
Kenny Ojeuderie 9
Where Watford
When 1 Sept 2005
Darina Pantaleeva 15
Where Haringey
When 5 June 2002
James Paterson 16
Where Glasgow
When 30 Dec 2000
Jonathan Paterson 16
Glasgow
When 30 Dec 2000
Guilia Paulet 9
Where UK
When 7 Dec 2000
Carmel Pendry 25
Where Crawley
When 23 May 1998
Yen Pham 16
Where Letchworth
When 25 June 2002
Anita Rajoelina 9
Where High Wycombe
When 15 Dec 2002
John Rodgers 45
Where Belfast
When 27 Nov 1974
Sean Ryan 25
Where Co Down
When 1 Sept 1998
Sean Ryan 25
Where Coventry
When 1 March 2005
Megan Scott 6
Where Newcastle
When 17 Mar 2006
Sian Scott 8
Where Newcastle
When 17 Mar 2006
Thomas Spence 43
Where Belfast
When 27 Nov 1974
Jasai Swan 9
Where Bermuda
When 18 Jan 2003
Siobhan Tate 16
Where Leeds
When 22 April 2006
Aden Tedros 23
Where London
When 11 July 1998
Jerome Thomas 21
Where Gwbert
When 1 Jan 2001
Robert Williams 20
Where Neath
When 22 March 2002
Zamaira Zorba 22
Where London
When 1 Aug 2000
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments