Fears World Cup will not deliver change in Qatar amid LGBTQ+ supporter concerns
Fans have reported having rainbow items confiscated by officials during the tournament in the Gulf state.
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Hosting the World Cup will not deliver meaningful change in Qatar, a senior MP has said, amid ongoing concerns over the Gulf state’s response to LGBTQ+ symbols.
Conservative MP Alicia Kearns, who chairs the Commons Foreign Affairs Committee, said “nothing about their behaviour has changed” since the country was awarded the hosting rights in 2010.
Fans have reported having rainbow items, including T-shirts and Wales bucket hats, confiscated by officials in Qatar during the tournament.
A Danish television journalist was also approached by police and told he could not wear a “One Love” rainbow-coloured armband while reporting in Qatar.
Denmark were among seven European national teams, including England and Wales, who dropped plans to wear the anti-discrimination armband following threats by Fifa to impose sporting sanctions.
Foreign Secretary James Cleverly said Qatar has “taken real steps” to ensure that “gay football fans are safe and do feel secure”.
But several LGBT+ supporters have opted not to travel to the tournament in a country where homosexuality is still illegal.
Downing Street said it is closely monitoring the treatment of UK fans at the World Cup.
Rutland and Melton MP Ms Kearns, when asked about her hopes for the tournament to deliver change in Qatar, told the PA news agency: “Yes, we should always be hopeful, but I do not meaningfully believe that holding the World Cup in Qatar is going to change anything on the ground.
“Because if it was going to, we wouldn’t have seen human rights abuses taking place, there wouldn’t have been the loss of life that we’ve seen taking place.
“Qatar has shown since it received the nomination to hold (the World Cup) that nothing about their behaviour has changed domestically or even regards to workers.
“So I really don’t think, unfortunately – and I wish this was not the case – that we can have any hope that things will meaningfully change.”
Mr Cleverly said gay rights is an issue he has “brought up over a number of years” with Qatar.
He told the BBC: “I’ve made it clear that we feel very strongly about this issue and, actually, one of the advantages about having a strong relationship with other countries is you can have these difficult conversations.
“The Qataris know how seriously we take this issue and they have taken real steps to ensure that gay football fans are safe and do feel secure and can enjoy the football.”
Shadow foreign secretary David Lammy said of the reports of fans having items confiscated: “I was really shocked and saddened to see that happen.
“It doesn’t feel to me to be in the spirit of the World Cup, from the reports that I’ve read.”
On the decision to be choose Qatar as host, the Tottenham Labour MP told PA: “I’m very conscious that, in the global community, there are countries that take a different view to the one that I hold on human rights issues – and I’m thinking here particularly of LGBTQ rights issues – which is why I don’t think it would be right for a Labour politician particularly to take hospitality from the Qatari government to go out and watch the games.
“But I do also believe in the universal power of sport to bring people together.
“This is the first Muslim country to host the World Cup.
“People are there able to have those difficult conversations about human rights abuses, about the treatment of migrant workers, to campaign, to make their voices heard. I think that’s right, and the international community is raising its voice in relation to these issues.
“But I recognise the power of football to bring people together and to change hearts and minds, and I hope some of that will flow from the games in Qatar.”
Wales First Minister Mark Drakeford attended his country’s opening game against the USA, although the Welsh delegation will boycott the Iran game before making an appearance for the final Group B fixture with England.
Mr Lammy, asked about Mr Drakeford’s decision to attend, said: “That is a matter for the Welsh Government. I think Mark Drakeford is there as a leader of his country, as a government, and that is a matter for him.
“But here in England we’ve been clear and Labour Members of Parliament aren’t attending.”
On the pitch, England fans are sweating on the fitness of Harry Kane as the captain prepares to undergo an ankle scan ahead of the Three Lions’ second game with the USA on Friday.