Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Liveupdated1727967553

UK politics live: Furious Chagos Islands row erupts as Tories accused of risking losing key air base in courts

Chagossians lament UK-Mauritius deal for not including them in negotiations

Salma Ouaguira
Thursday 03 October 2024 10:59
Comments
Minister says accepting freebies is different in government

Your support helps us to tell the story

My recent work focusing on Latino voters in Arizona has shown me how crucial independent journalism is in giving voice to underrepresented communities.

Your support is what allows us to tell these stories, bringing attention to the issues that are often overlooked. Without your contributions, these voices might not be heard.

Every dollar you give helps us continue to shine a light on these critical issues in the run up to the election and beyond

Head shot of Eric Garcia

Eric Garcia

Washington Bureau Chief

A furious row has erupted between Labour and the Conservatives over a deal to hand over the Chagos Islands to Mauritius.

Sir Keir Starmer’s government has announced that Britain will return the territory but will still have sovereignty over the Diego Garcia military base in the Pacific Ocean.

But the Conservatives have condemned the decision, with Tory leadership contender Robert Jenrick accusing Sir Keir Starmer of “surrendering” Britain’s strategic interests.

Former foreign secretary James Cleverly has also joined the backlash, branding Sir Keir Starmer “weak, weak, weak” despite being behind the first negotiations over the agreement when he was in cabinet.

A Labour source hit back accusing Rishi Sunak’s administration of putting the key UK-US base on Diego Garcia at risk during their negotiations.

They branded the territorial dispute a “legal car crash” left by the previous government which was “damaging the UK and the US’ national security”.

It comes as Boris Johnson revealed how he dismissed warnings over Dominic Cummings and the Barnard Castle row as “lefty journalists angry over Brexit”.

In his new book ‘Unleashed’, the former prime minister explained why he refused to sack his then-political adviser despite his infamous trip at the peak of the pandemic.

1727965068

We inherited ‘legal car crash’ with Chagos Islands

A Labour source has hit back at the Tories’ after the fierce criticism from leadership candidates over the government’s decision to return the Chagos Islands to Mauritius.

They said: “Labour inherited a legal car crash that could have left this vital military base in the hands of the court, damaging the UK and the US’ national security.”

In 2021, the Conservative government was urged to end its “unlawful occupation” of the Chagos Islands by the prime minister of Mauritius after Britain’s claim to sovereignty was rejected by the UN court.

But the Foreign Office argued it had not been party of the court proceedings so it was under no obligation to comply with the ruling.

The UK then underwent a long period of negotiations with Mauritius to settle the issue.

The source added: “James Cleverly and the Tories tried and failed in 11 rounds of negotiations, putting our national security interests at risk.

“The new government did the deal to secure the base and shut off a potential illegal migration route.

“You wouldn’t get the US President applauding the deal if it put US interests at risk.”

Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 15:17
1727964603

COMMENT | Laura Kuenssberg’s Boris Johnson gaffe was bad – but these are worse

The BBC presenter accidentally sent the former PM her notes: cue, cancelled interview. And Ryan Coogan has a few confessions of his own…

Laura Kuenssberg’s Boris Johnson gaffe was bad – but these are even worse

The BBC presenter accidentally sent the former PM her notes: cue, cancelled interview. And Ryan Coogan has a few confessions of his own…

Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 15:10
1727963403

ICYMI: Boris Johnson regrets not sacking ‘homicidal robot’ Dominic Cummings over Barnard Castle debacle

Boris Johnson has branded his former chief of staff Dominic Cummings as “weird” and compared him to a “homicidal robot” as he blamed him for his downfall as prime minister.

In his new autobiography Unleashed, the Mr Johnson charted the collapse of his relationship with Cummings from the high point of them working to win the EU referendum in 2016.

But he has alleged that Cummings lack of gratitude for his efforts to defend him over potentially breaking lockdown rules with an infamous trip to Barnard Castle in 2020 led to the former chief of staff using Partygate as a form of revenge.

Our political editor David Maddox has the full story below:

Boris regrets not sacking ‘homicidal robot’ Cummings over Barnard Castle debacle

Boris Johnson had a blazing row with one of his closest former advisers over not sacking Cummings over alleged lockdown breaches and claims after that things got ‘weirder’

Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 14:50
1727962200

THE INDEPENDENT DEBATE: Who should be the next leader of the Tory party?

Share your thoughts by adding them in the comments — we’ll highlight the most insightful ones as they come in.

All you have to do is sign up and register your details — then you can take part in the discussion. You can also sign up by clicking ‘log in’ on the top right-hand corner of the screen.

(Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire)
Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 14:30
1727961042

Chagos Islands envoy brands Tory criticism ‘silly’ and ‘ludicrous'

Jonathan Powell, who was appointed only a month ago, has been at the forefront of the Chagos Islands’ negotiations.

The former Tony Blair’s chief of staff was also a key figure in negotiating the Good Friday agreement.

Mr Powell said the securing the deal was “genuinely historic” and he had negotiated “intensively”.

Asked about the criticism from Tory leadership candidates on the deal, he said: “I do think these comments from the Tory leadership candidates are a bit silly.

“James Cleverly was leading these negotiations not that many months ago with the Mauritian government [when he was foreign secretary].”

He added: “What this government has done has been able to conclude it, because that government managed to lose the trust of the Mauritian government during the process.

“So for the people who were involved in that negotiation to start criticising the outcome of something they couldn’t achieve is absolutely ludicrous.”

Jonathan Powell
Jonathan Powell (Getty Images)
Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 14:10
1727959835

Grant Shapps joins Tory furore

(Twitter: @grantshapps)
Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 13:50
1727959182

Nigel Farage says ‘giving up Chagos Islands is strategic disaster’

The Reform UK leader told The Telegraph: “Giving up the Chagos Islands is a strategic disaster.

“Our American allies will be furious and Beijing delighted. Labour are making the world a more dangerous place.”

Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 13:39
1727958642

ICYMI: Cleverly condemns Chagos Islands deal - which he initiated

James Cleverly has condemned Sir Keir Starmer as “weak, weak, weak” for handing the Chagos Islands to Mauritius - despite having kicked off negotiations over the deal when he was foreign secretary.

After a barnstorming conference, which catapulted Mr Cleverly to second favourite in the Tory leadership contest, the misstep threatened to derail his momentum.

Our politics team has the full story below:

James Cleverly condemns Chagos Islands deal - which he initiated

After a barnstorming conference, which catapulted Mr Cleverly to second favourite in the Tory leadership contest, the Chagos Islands news threatens to derail his momentum

Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 13:30
1727958010

Reform MP accuses government of ‘undermining British interests'

Rupert Lowe has joined the Tories in criticising the government’s decision to return the Chagos Islands to Mauritius.

The Reform MP tweeted: “The British government is now actively undermining British interests overseas. A total surrender.

“Speaking to contacts in Gibraltar, they are incredibly concerned following the Chagos Islands capitulation - ‘the thin end of the wedge’...

“The message is loud and clear - this Labour government is a disgrace.”

Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 13:20
1727957400

Your Tory Party conference questions answered by John Rentoul

This year’s Conservative Party conference in Birmingham provides a pivotal moment for reflection and debate.

It stands in stark contrast to the 2023 gathering, when Rishi Sunak’s government made a series of last-minute policy announcements, including offshoring prisoners, cutting civil servants, and controversially scrapping HS2.

As the conference unfolds, our chief political commentator John Rentoul has been answering your burning questions on the leadership contest, the fallout from the election defeat, and more.

Salma Ouaguira3 October 2024 13:10

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in