Health secretary sparks outrage with ‘doctors in training’ remark
Victoria Atkins causes fury with her remarks about junior doctors, as strike row heats up
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Victoria Atkins was accused of insulting junior doctors after the health secretary said she liked to call them “doctors in training”.
The Tory cabinet minister dangled the prospected of an improved offer on pay and conditions on the second day of junior doctors’ 72-hour strike.
But Ms Atkins sparked outrage by using a different term for the group while speaking about pay deals agreed with other health service workers.
“The last cohort is junior doctors – or doctors in training, as I prefer to call them – and they, sadly to my great disappointment, walked out of our negotiations and then called these strikes.”
Senior Labour MP Chris Bryant immediately fired back at the health secretary on X: “They’re doctors. Doctors. Not doctors in training.”
Labour’s shadow health secretary Wes Streeting tweeted: “I prefer to call them doctors.” And shadow care minister Andrew Gwynne added: “How insulting … They are doctors, they save lives every day.”
Several commentators on social media also referred to Ms Atkins’ remarks as “insulting”. But Ms Atkins responded to the criticism by pointing to the fact that it was a term the British Medical Association (BMA) has used.
While junior doctors do receive some clinical training while in the job, they are qualified doctors and Ms Atkins’ term “doctors in training” is not one used in the NHS.
The BMA later said that it does not like the “infantilising” term “junior doctors” and does prefer “doctors in training” – but said the phrase was not ideal.
A spokesperson said: “Whilst ‘doctors in training’ is a stepping stone in nomenclature, it may still suggest that doctors are not yet qualified, when in fact they are, but are developing further skills and experience towards a specialty.”
In her interviews, Ms Atkins also sought to highlight splits between junior doctors’ leaders in the British Medical Association (BMA) and other NHS staff – claiming some were “deeply uncomfortable” with the industrial action over Christmas.
But the health secretary hinted that an improved offer on pay and conditions could be on the table if the junior doctors called off the industrial action.
She told BBC Breakfast that health department ministers and officials would be “back round the table in 20 minutes” for talks if the strikes are called off “and then we can see how much further we can go”.
A 72-hour England-wide walkout, which began at 7am on 20 December and will run until Saturday, comes as the NHS grapples with one of its toughest winters on record. It will be followed by a six-day walkout from 3 January.
The NHS has said emergency and urgent care will be prioritised during the strikes over Christmas and New Year and that “almost all” routine care will be affected.
More than 300,000 operations and appointments are reportedly set to be cancelled during the strikes. It could push NHS waiting lists, currently at 7.7 million, above eight million for the first time ever, according to analysis by The Times.
Hospital leaders have described the walkouts as their “worst fears realised” as they grapple with a rising number of people needing help with winter viruses, particularly norovirus.
Ms Atkins told BBC Radio 4’s Today there will be “many, many doctors listening to this who feel deeply uncomfortable that their committee has called these strikes at this time”.
She said consultants, nurses and other doctors would be coming in to do extra shifts. “They are being expected by the junior doctors’ committee to pick up the slack of their strikes,” she added.
“After the three Christmases that our medical profession has seen with Covid, I think we all wanted this Christmas to be as calm and settled as possible. Instead, this strike action is just striking through that.”
The BMA’s junior doctors’ committee has challenged the government to make an offer first, so strikes could be cancelled.
It said the offer from the government, an average 3 per cent rise from January – on top of the average of nearly 9 per cent recommended by the independent pay review body in April – was not enough to make up for below-inflation pay rises since 2008.
It has asked for a full pay restoration that the government said would amount to a 35 per cent pay rise, which ministers have said is unaffordable. Conciliation service Acas said it is “ready to help” resolve the dispute.
Elsewhere, Ms Atkins has written to the bodies which recommend salary uplifts for NHS staff to ask them to begin looking at the pay round for 2024/25 – but unions warned she had left it too late.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments