Voter ID plan is 'ineffective' and could disenfranchise tens of thousands of voters, report finds
Around 340 voters turned away from ballot box in pilot areas during May elections and did not return because they did not have required ID, warns Electoral Reform Society
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Government plans to introduce voter ID checks could disenfranchise tens of thousands of people and is an ineffective way to cut down on voter fraud, a report has found.
The Electoral Reform Society (ERS) has highlighted concerns about the potential consequences of forcing voters to show ID documents at the polling station, saying it is akin to “rearranging the deckchairs while our democracy heads towards an iceberg”.
It comes as the Constitution Minister Chloe Smith told MPs on Tuesday the government was rolling the practice out nationally, while also admitting she had no idea how much the wider scheme would cost.
Pilots of voter ID schemes were carried out in the UK's 3 May local elections this year, during which The Independent revealed a number of people were denied the right to vote.
The planned introduction has since raised concerns it may make it more difficult for vulnerable groups like those with disabilities, the homeless and older voters to cast their ballot.
The report found around 340 voters were turned away from the ballot box at the pilots and did not return because they did not have the required ID.
It concludes: “Requiring voters to present identification at the polling station is a disproportionate and ineffective response to the extremely rare incidence of voter fraud.
“Not only does it not address the alleged ‘problem’ of personation, but it has the potential to stifle electoral participation among legitimate voters, and to have a particularly discriminatory effect on the most vulnerable and disengaged groups.”
The government said an “overwhelming majority” of people cast their vote without a problem and said it planned to continue to pilot ID at next year’s local elections.
During an evidence session with the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Select Committee (PACAC), Ms Smith said the 340 voters was a “very small number”, at 0.14 per cent.
In the same hearing, she claimed the 28 voters in the country suspected of voter fraud in 2017 – 0.000063 per cent of the population - showed an “obvious weakness in our democracy“.
Jess Garland, director of research at the ERS, said: “When it comes to voter ID, the government is rearranging the deckchairs while our democracy heads towards an iceberg.
“Revelations about serious wrongdoing during the Brexit campaign have shaken faith in our elections, with online campaigning starting to look like a ‘wild west’ beyond the reach of our regulations.”
Ms Garland said if the scheme was rolled out nationally it could cost the taxpayer up to £20m per general election and, based on this year’s trials, could disenfranchise tens of thousands of voters.
“These are significant numbers – and the disenfranchising effect of voter ID could easily swing the result of future elections,” she said, adding: “The government should abandon these costly, undemocratic plans and focus on boosting democratic engagement instead.”
During the pilot in May, a 76-year-old man who had lived in Bromley for 40 years told The Independent he was “shocked” to be turned away because he did not have a bank card or passport.
Under the pilot scheme, voters were required to produce accepted identity documents including a passport, driving licence, European ID card or Oyster 60+ London Pass.
Dozens of campaign organisations, including Age UK, the Salvation Army, Stonewall and Operation Black Vote, have previously called for the new laws to be scrapped.
Cat Smith MP, Labour’s Shadow Minister for voter engagement and youth affairs, said it was “staggering” the government planned to “waste tens of millions of pounds on mandatory ID checks in polling stations”.
She added: “The Windrush scandal has demonstrated that it can be difficult for some communities to provide official documentation, yet the government remains wedded to their undemocratic and unaffordable plans.
UK news in pictures
UK news in pictures
-
1/5010 September 2018
Alastair Cook celebrates his century in his last ever innings playing for England during the fourth day of the fifth test cricket match against India at The Oval. He announced his retirement before the fifth test match began, ending his illustrious 12-year test career
AFP/Getty
-
2/509 September 2018
Sir Mo Farah winning the The Great North Run’s elite men’s race, claiming a record-breaking fifth consecutive victory. He completed the race in under an hour
Getty/Nike
-
3/508 September 2018
Britain’s former foreign secretary Boris Johnson sits in the stands during play on the second day of the fifth Test cricket match between England and India at The Oval in London
AFP/Getty
-
4/507 September 2018
The poppy sculpture Wave by artist Paul Cummins and designer Tom Piper at IWM North, The Quays, Manchester. This is the final presentation of Wave as part of a four year UK-wide tour, and the sculpture will be on site until 25 November
PA
-
5/506 September 2018
The aftermath of a house fire, which broke out in the early hours of the morning, where a woman died in Centurion Square, south-east London.
PA
-
6/505 September 2018
Counter-terrorism police have released images of the two suspects in connection with the Salisbury attack in March. The suspects Ruslan Boshirov and Alexander Petrov, are Russian nationals, and approximately 40 years old. They travelled on a Russian passport and it is likely that they were travelling under aliases and that these are not their real names. The CPS has issued European Arrest Warrants for the extradition in connection with the Novichok poisoning attack on Sergei Skripal
Metropolitan Police
-
7/504 September 2018
Pro Labour party leader, Jeremy Corbyn, protesters demonstrate outside the Labour party headquarters in London. Labour’s NEC (National Executive Committee) is expected to approve the international definition of anti-Semitism into Labour’s code of conduct
EPA
-
8/503 September 2018
Chris Evans surrounded by media as he leaves the Radio 2 studio in London after he announced he is quitting his breakfast show which he has presented since 2010
PA
-
9/502 September 2018
Former Labour Prime Minister Gordon Brown speaks during the ‘Jewish Labour Movement Conference’
Getty
-
10/501 September 2018
An inflatable caricature balloon of Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan floats, near Parliament Square in London. Organizer Yanny Bruere raised more than 58,000 pounds ($75,000) through the Crowdfunder website for the 29-foot (8.8-meter) blimp as part of a campaign to oust Khan from his post. Khan angered some people in the British capital and elsewhere last month when he allowed a balloon caricaturing Donald Trump as an angry baby to float above the city while the U.S. president was in England.
AP
-
11/5031 August 2018
A can of Coca-Cola next to a cup of Costa coffee, as Whitbread has struck a deal to sell the Costa Coffee chain to Coca-Cola for £3.9 billion
PA
-
12/5030 August 2018
Frank Field MP in Westminster, London, after resigning from the Labour party over the anti-Semitism crisis. Field, who has represented Birkenhead from almost 40 years, revealed in a letter to party chief whip Nick Brown that he could no longer serve the party as the leadership was overseeing the “erosion of our core values”
PA
-
13/5029 August 2018
The Duke and Duchess of Sussex meeting ‘King George’ and the cast at the Victoria Palace Theatre in London after attending a gala performance of the musical Hamilton, in support of Sentebale. The evening raises awareness and funds for Sentebale’s work with children and young people affected by HIV in southern Africa
Dan Charity/The Sun/PA
-
14/5028 August 2018
Prime Minister Theresa May meets students and staff at I.D. Mkize Secondary School in Cape Town, which is twinned with Whitby High School in Yorkshire. The two schools are part of a British Council funded teacher exchange scheme called ‘Connected Classrooms’. The prime minister is on day one of her trip to South Africa, Nigeria and Kenya on a trade mission designed to bolster the UK’s post-Brexit fortunes
PA
-
15/5027 August 2018
Performers take part in the main Parade day of Notting Hill Carnival in London. Nearly one million people are expected by the organizers over Sunday and Monday in the streets of west London to celebrate Caribbean culture, which is considered the largest street demonstration in Europe
AFP/Getty
-
16/5026 August 2018
The crowd pauses for 72 seconds silence in remembrance of all those lost in the Grenfell Tower fire at the Red Bull Music Academy Sound System at Notting Hill
Getty
-
17/5025 August 2018
Comedian Rose Matafeo is congratulated by Steve Coogan after winning the Edinburgh Comedy Award at the Dovecote Studio
PA
-
18/5024 August 2018
British Secretary of State for International Trade, Liam Fox, attends a signing ceremony for memorandums of understanding between British and Chinese firms and institutions at the British ambassador’s residence in Beijing
AP
-
19/5023 August 2018
Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe hugs her daughter Gabriella, in Iran. She has been allowed to leave an Iranian prison for three days. Zaghari-Ratcliffe was arrested during a holiday with her toddler daughter in April 2016. Iranian authorities accuse her of plotting against the government. Her family denies this, saying says she was in Iran to visit family
Free Nazanin Campaign/AP
-
20/5022 August 2018
Anti Brexit activists protest as they deliver a pile of medical supplies in cardboard boxes to the Department of Health and Social Care in London. Our Future, Our Choice (OFOC) Pro EU campaign group wants get its message to the public surrounding the predicted costs of Britain’s “No Deal Hard Brexit”, exit from the European Union
AP
-
21/5021 August 2018
Families enjoy rides on the dodgems during an Eid in the Park celebration marking Eid Al-Adha at the New River Sports ground in Wood Green, London. The traditional four-day celebratory festival marks one of the holiest days in the Islamic religious calendar
Getty
-
22/5020 August 2018
Jeremy Corbyn campaigns on Labour’s ‘Build it in Britain’ policy at Alexander Dennis bus manufacturers in Falkirk,Scotland. The Labour leader will spend the next four days in Scotland in an attempt to revitalize the party there
Getty
-
23/5019 August 2018
Manchester United women’s side walk out alongside Liverpool ahead of their first professional game since 2005. United disbanded their senior women’s team thirteen years ago and returned with a win, beating Liverpool in their Continental Tyres Cup match clash at Prenton Park
PA
-
24/5018 August 2018
Great Britain’s Reece Prescod, finishes second, to USA’s Christian Coleman, centre, in a photo finish after they both ran 9.94. With USA’s Noah Lyles, left, finishing third in the men’s 100m final during the Muller Grand Prix at Alexander Stadium, Birmingham
PA
-
25/5017 August 2018
Paul Elliott, right, carries the coffin of his brother Barry, 73, at the New York Stadium, Rotherham, for his funeral following his death on Sunday August 5. The veteran entertainer was one half of comedy duo the Chuckle Brothers with Paul
PA
-
26/5016 August 2018
Students react as they receive their ‘A’ level results at Stoke Newington School and Sixth Form in London. Universities accepted thousands fewer students as pass rates hit lowest level since 2010
Reuters
-
27/5015 August 2018
People gather on Market Street, Omagh, for the ceremony to mark the 20th anniversary of the Omagh bombing on 15 August 1998. The worst single atrocity of the Northern Ireland conflict killed 29, including a woman pregnant with twins
PA
-
28/5014 August 2018
Police arrest a man after he crashed a car into security barriers outside the Houses of Parliament
Sky News
-
29/5013 August 2018
Communities Secretary James Brokenshire today launched a £100 million pound government fund to end rough sleeping in England within the next decade. Brokenshire is pictured here at the central London headquarters for homelessness charity the Passage, where he launched the scheme
PA
-
30/5012 August 2018
Police officers stand guard at the scene of a shooting at Claremont Road in the Moss Side neighborhood of Manchester, Ten people were taken to hospital on August 12, 2018 after shots were fired in Manchester in northern England, police said.
AFP/Getty
-
31/5011 August 2018
Great Britain’s Dina Asher-Smith reacts after she won gold in the women’s 200m final at the European Athletics Championships in Berlin, completing the sprint double after she won the 100m just days before
Getty/European Athletics
-
32/5010 August 2018
Pedestrians walk past the entrance of the retail store House of Fraser in central London. The Chinese-owned UK department store chain, entered administration on August 10 only to be swiftly snapped up by retailer Sports Direct for £90 million ($115 million, 100 million euros)
AFP/Getty
-
33/509 August 2018
Local people protest outside the Hillingdon Conservative Association office on August 9, 2018 in Uxbridge, England. Today’s protest is being held following comments made by former Foreign Secretary, Boris Johnson, against the wearing of Burkas by Muslim women in the United Kingdom. An independent panel will investigate complaints made regarding Mr Johnson’s comments and possible breaches of the Conservative Party code of conduct.
Getty
-
34/508 August 2018
Britain’s Prince William, right, and Britain’s Prime Minister Theresa May, walk past a German flag, left, and a Britain’s flag as they leave the Amiens cathedral, northern France. Prince William and Theresa May are marking the somber centenary of the Battle of Amiens, in France, a short, bloody and decisive battle that heralded the end of World War I
AP
-
35/507 August 2018
Great Britain’s Jack Laugher and James Heatly pose with their Gold and Bronze medal’s respectively won in the 1 metre springboard men’s final at the European Diving Championships in Glasgow
EPA
-
36/506 August 2018
England cricketer Ben Stokes arrives at Bristol Crown Court accused of affray. The 27-year-old all-rounder and two other men, Ryan Ali and Ryan Hale are jointly charged with affray in the Clifton Triangle area of Bristol on September 25 last year, several hours after England had played a one-day international against the West Indies in the city
PA
-
37/505 August 2018
Great Britain’s Laura Kenny celebrates after winning the Women’s Elimination Race final at the European Championships in Glasgow
-
38/504 August 2018
Ben Stokes celebrates taking the wicket of India’s Hardik Pandya with team mates during the first test at Edgbaston
Action Images via Reuters
-
39/503 August 2018
French President Emmanuel Macron waves to people as he arrives at the Fort de Bregancon for a meeting with British Prime Minister Theresa May
epa
-
40/502 August 2018
Brexit Minister Dominic Raab is welcomed by French Minister attached to the Foreign Affairs Minister Nathalie Loiseau prior to a meeting in Paris
AFP/Getty
-
41/501 August 2018
Demonstrators against Tommy Robinson outside the Royal Courts of Justice in London, where the former English Defence League leader has been freed on bail by the Court of Appeal after winning a challenge against a finding of contempt of court
PA
-
42/5031 July 2018
Friends of Lucy McHugh gather in Mansel Park, Southampton to release balloons in her memory. Lucy disappeared from her Southampton home last Wednesday and her body was later found in woodland near Southampton Sports Centre at 7.45am on Thursday
PA
-
43/5030 July 2018
Foreign Secretary Jeremy Hunt followed in the footsteps of his gaffe-prone predecessor Boris Johnson as he mistakenly referred to his Chinese wife as Japanese whilst on his first diplomatic mission to China
AP
-
44/5029 July 2018
Britain’s Geraint Thomas, left, wearing the overall leader’s yellow jersey and Britain’s Luke Rowe hold the flag of Wales during the 21st and last stage of the 105th edition of the Tour de France cycling race between Houilles and Paris Champs-Elysees. Thomas is the first Welshman to win the Tour de France
AP
-
45/5028 July 2018
Passengers wait and queue following flight disruption at London Stansted Airport. The British National Air Traffic Services (Nats) placed temporary restrictions during the adverse weather on 27 July leading to flight cancellations and delays across Britain
EPA
-
46/5027 July 2018
The scene on the A96 between Huntly and Keith in Moray where a five people have died and five more were injured after a crash between a minibus and a car.
PA
-
47/5026 July 2018
Anti-Brexit campaigners parked a removal van outside the Foreign Secretary’s official home in central London in protest of former Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson’s continued residence there
PA
-
48/5025 July 2018
Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn during his visit to HS2 trains bidder Bombardier in Derby, following the launch of the party’s new Build it in Britain campaign
PA
-
49/5024 July 2018
Great Britain’s Geraint Thomas cleans his eyes after tear gas was thrown at the pelaton during a farmers’ protest who attempted to block the stage’s route, during the 16th stage of the Tour de France, between Carcassonne and Bagneres-de-Luchon. The race was halted for several minutes.
AFP/Getty Images
-
50/5023 July 2018
Crime scene investigators at the scene near the Hilton Hotel, Deansgate, Manchester where a woman with serious injuries to her neck was found in the morning. Six people have been arrested on suspicion of attempted murder after the woman was attacked inside the hotel
PA
“The government should stop trying to make it harder for people to vote and abandon next year’s pilot schemes as a matter of urgency.”
A Cabinet Office spokesperson said: “Voters deserve to be confident that their vote is protected.
“We already ask that people prove who they are in order to collect a parcel from the post office, rent a car, or travel abroad – and we believe it is right to take the same approach to protect voting rights.
“Evaluation from the May 2019 pilots will further inform how voter ID should work on a national scale, including costs and what approach will work best for voters and the taxpayer.”
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments