Bibby Stockholm: Home Office under fresh scrutiny over migrant barge ‘incompetence’
Six asylum seekers moved onto barge despite initial results indicating bacteria was present
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.The Home Office is facing mounting pressure over its “startling incompetence” after asylum seekers had to be evacuated from the Bibby Stockholm barge following the discovery of Legionella bacteria.
Conservative backbenchers have accused the department of overseeing a “farce” after the 39 people who had boarded the vessel were transferred to alternative accommodation on Friday evening.
Shadow immigration minister Stephen Kinnock also wrote to his opposite number on Saturday asking what the Home Office knew about the risk of the bacteria being present before moving migrants onto the barge.
Department officials are understood to have been told by Dorset Council on Wednesday evening about the discovery of initial results indicating that the bacteria was present, but the transfer of a further six migrants onto the barge still went ahead on Thursday.
Government sources said the UK Health Security Agency then told ministers on Thursday that Legionella had been found in the vessel’s water system and advised them that they needed to remove those six migrants.
Former Brexit secretary David Davis said the barge would not serve as a “solution” to the backlog even without the presence of the bacteria.
He told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “The primary thing that’s been revealed has been the startling incompetence of the Home Office itself … It’s really, really hard to understand how, at all layers, this could not be caught early.”
The senior Conservative MP suggested the problems could be related to “management” of the department rather than “ministerial” issues specifically, but added: “Even working properly, the Bibby barge would only take effectively one day’s arrivals.
“So it’s not a solution to the problem and all of this is going to go on until the Home Office is able to process these arrivals more quickly.”
The department said all 39 of those on board had been disembarked as a “precautionary measure” after samples from the water system showed levels of legionella requiring further investigation.
The Home Office said no migrants have fallen sick or developed legionnaires’ disease, which is a serious type of pneumonia, and that they are all being provided with “appropriate advice and support”.
But Tim Loughton said the evacuation was an “embarrassment” and smacked of “incompetence,” coming at the end of a week in which the government had planned a series of announcements aimed at promoting its immigration approach.
The Tory MP said: “This is deeply troubling and rapidly turning into a farce that the Home Office can ill afford.”
Immigration minister Robert Jenrick has been urged by Mr Kinnock to answer a series of questions about the “extremely troubling matter” of the evacuation.
“This whole sorry affair is yet another shambolic example of the chaos, incompetence and confusion that have come to define the way in which this government is dealing with the asylum crisis that it has created,” the shadow minister wrote.
“Why should the British public trust you to deal effectively with this mess when every measure you announce either fails to deliver, never gets off the ground, or just makes everything worse?”
Mr Kinnock later tweeted: “Has anyone seen Suella Braverman?”
If inhaled, Legionella bacteria can cause legionnaires’ disease, a type of severe pneumonia.
It can grow in man-made water systems, particularly if the plumbing has not been used in months.
Public health expert Professor Paul Hunter said the bacteria would have been an obvious risk to test for before moving people onto the barge.
He said it was possible those on board could have been exposed to Legionella if they took a shower because this can generate a mist of the bacteria which can be inhaled, although the Home Office has said no one has fallen ill.
“Certainly if we … had had a [hospital] ward that had not been open for a number of weeks and the water was still in the pipes, we would check that before we actually started moving patients into that ward, and this didn’t seem to happen. This is very concerning,” Prof Hunter told Today.
With a stated capacity of more than 500, the government hopes that the use of Bibby Stockholm will help cut the £6m a day currently being spent on hotel bills for asylum seekers awaiting the outcome of their applications.
The Home Office has been contacted for fresh comment but a spokesperson said on Friday: “The health and welfare of asylum seekers remains of the utmost priority.
“The Home Office and our contractors are following all protocol and advice from Dorset Council’s environmental health team, UK Health Security Agency and Dorset NHS who we are working closely with.”