Independent review planned for New York's COVID-19 response

An independent auditor will review the New York state government's response to the COVID-19 pandemic, including efforts by the administration of the previous governor to downplay the number of deaths of nursing home residents.

The state plans to select an independent auditor, who would have until late 2023 to deliver a final report, under a timeline released Tuesday by current Gov. Kathy Hochul's office. Initial findings are expected in May.

The report will include a planning guide for future emergencies and will explore issues from the transfer of nursing home patients to the reopening of schools and businesses to efforts to purchase needed medical supplies.

The governor, who is running for her first full term in November and won the recent June Democratic gubernatorial primary, promised in mid-March to eventually launch a review of the state’s COVID-19 response.

Critics, including Republicans and Democratic Assemblymember Ron Kim, have said the Hochul administration has waited far too long to launch an investigation.

Hochul's spokesperson, Hazel Crampton-Hays, said the timing of the investigation is not connected to New York's political calendar.

"New Yorkers who have lived through being at the epicenter of a global pandemic, lost loved ones, and experienced economic hardship deserve a thoughtful, meaningful, and independent after action review, and we won’t rush through this important work for the political calendar,” Crampton-Hays said in a statement.

Kim said the independent auditors must probe the handling of COVID-19 outbreaks at nursing homes and other long-term care facilities, including the impact of efforts by the administration of former Gov. Andrew Cuomo, a Democrat, to obscure the COVID-19 death toll by excluding out-of-facility deaths.

That toll excluded the deaths of over 4,000 New Yorkers, according to numbers released by the state in January 2021 in the wake of a damning attorney general report. Attorney General Letitia James' report also found a lack of infection controls at nursing homes put residents at increased risk of harm.

What "was the intent behind hiding the accurate death toll numbers, which precluded the legislators from intervening sooner on behalf of their panicked constituents?” Kim, a Queens lawmaker who has said his uncle died of suspected COVID-19 in a New York nursing home, said in a statement.

Cuomo and his administration used that incomplete data to erroneously claim that New York's share of COVID-19 deaths of nursing home residents was among the nation's lowest. A March report by state Comptroller Tom DiNapoli called that claim “misleading” and said Cuomo officials should have known its data wasn't comparable to other states that included out-of-facility deaths.

Kim also wants scrutiny of a March 2020 directive that barred nursing homes from rejecting recovering coronavirus patients being discharged from hospitals.

James' report found that directive “may have contributed to increased risk of nursing home resident infection and subsequent fatalities.”

But James said the state needs additional data and analysis to conclusively prove such a link.

DiNapoli also found “persistent underinvestment in public health” may have hampered New York's pandemic response, as local and state health agencies struggled with inadequate staffing.

The Cuomo administration also faced criticism over health care workers' lack of access to masks and other needed COVID-19 supplies in the pandemic's early days.

Zucker repeatedly assured the public that New York had enough stockpiles of medical supplies at multiple public appearances from mid-January through February 2020.

But an AP review of state expenditure reports found Zucker’s agency only began spending far above average on medical supplies by March 19, when spending jumped from $1.6 million to $9 million.

Hospitals fearing supply shortages in spring 2020 instituted policies in some cases requiring use of a single surgical mask for as long as a week.