The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

8 best dog collars for your four-legged friend, tried and tested

Make sure your pup is always looking on point with these practical accessories

Tamara Hinson
Wednesday 28 September 2022 09:00 EDT
We tried out the collars on two very different dogs – a Bedlington terrier and an enormous Rhodesian Ridgeback
We tried out the collars on two very different dogs – a Bedlington terrier and an enormous Rhodesian Ridgeback (The Independent)
Our Top Picks

More people are choosing to become dog owners than ever before, and, although there’s no denying splashing out on new dog toys is a whole lot of fun, there are plenty of practical accessories that require a little more decision-making. Collars are a case in point.

One of the first things you should do is measure your dog’s neck – not just so you know what size of collar to buy, but so you can keep track of how quickly your dog is growing, and will know when the collar might need changing.

The right collar should have plenty of room for adjustment, and you should be able to squeeze two fingers between the collar and your dog’s fur with ease. Regularly check the area of fur beneath the collar – if it looks as though fur has been rubbed away, or there’s any chafed skin on show, it’s time to invest in a different collar.

How we tested

Luckily, we’ve got two discerning test dogs at our disposal – a Bedlington terrier named Honey and an enormous Rhodesian Ridgeback called Barley. They’re two very different dogs with very different requirements – Barley is, quite simply, so strong that we suspect she might actually be a horse, while Honey is a pint-sized pooch with a penchant for accessorising (or, at least, that’s what we tell ourselves every time we add to her already-bursting wardrobe).

Either way, as dog-lovers who spend much of their time marching through the Surrey countryside with various dogs in tow, you can rest assured these collars were thoroughly tested. Comfort, style and practicality were all carefully assessed, and every single one of the collars below was given the seal of approval by our test dogs.

The best dog collars for 2023 are:

  • Best dog collar overall – Joules coastal pet collar: £14, Amazon.co.uk
  • Best budget dog collar – Pets at Home spotty dog collar, medium: £4, Petsathome.com
  • Best dog collar for posh pooches – Holland Cooper HC classic dog collar: £79, Hollandcooper.com
  • Best dog collar for durability – 3 Peaks lightweight mesh dog collar, small/medium: £6, Petsathome.com

Joules coastal pet collar

jouless .jpg
  • Best: Dog collar overall
  • Sizes: S-XL
  • Materials: Nylon
  • Colourways: Yellow stripe, red stripe
  • Why we love it
    • Sturdy and tough

This gorgeous dog collar, with its hat trick of go-faster stripes, is built to last. It’s made from a thick, tough material and has sturdy metal fittings that not only allowed for the attachment of ID tags but kept the lead firmly in place, and ensured our test dog didn’t go for free-range walkabouts when she wasn’t meant to. We loved that there are four sizes available, too. The best bit? For dogs (or dog owners, at least) partial to a bit of colour coordination, the collar can be paired with a dog lead from the same collection.

Back to top

Pets at Home spotty dog collar, medium

pets at home .jpg
  • Best: Budget dog collar
  • Sizes: Medium
  • Materials: Nylon
  • Colourways: Purple
  • Why we love it
    • Inexpensive
    • Ultra tough

Who doesn’t love a purple polka-dot collar? Actually, your dog is probably indifferent, given that dogs are colour blind, but that’s beside the point.

This wallet-friendly collar, designed with medium-sized dogs in mind, and crafted from ultra-tough nylon material – paired with a sturdy D-ring clip for leads, and a quick-release buckle – makes it ideal for dogs who aren’t afraid of a little rough and tumble.

Back to top

Walk & Wear thunderbolt collar

ziggy .jpg
  • Best: Dog collar for hipster hounds
  • Sizes: XS, S, M, L
  • Materials: Polyester
  • Colourways: 32
  • Why we love it
    • Soft lining

Unlike many collars, these jazzy dog accessories, which come in four sizes and a range of designs and colourways printed onto water-resistant polyester, can be machine washed at 30C.

We love the ultra-soft neoprene inner lining, which isn’t just quick-drying but means minimal chafing, too, and the plastic clip stays securely in place without adding the extra weight associated with metal ones.

While the thunderbolt design we tested isn’t available at the moment, there’s a number of other styles to choose from, including pastel lilac, khaki and mint green.

Back to top

Stocky & Dee rainbow handmade dog collar

stocky dee .jpg
  • Best: Dog collar for a splash of colour
  • Sizes: Toy breed, XS, S/thin, S, M, L, XL
  • Materials: Merino lambswool, cotton
  • Colourways: Multicoloured
  • Why we love it
    • Thick
    • Soft on the inside
    • Wide range of sizes

Although we’d like to reassure readers that our reviews are based on our own first-hand experience, not the thoughts of our dog, there’s no denying our four-legged tester, Honey, had an instant attraction to this handmade collar. It’s wonderfully thick and feels fabulously soft, especially on the inside. It’s also one of the classiest collars we’ve come across, and is adorned with a chic metal pendant bearing the brand’s logo, and a metal clasp that clicks solidly into place. There are even seven sizes to choose from.

Back to top

Brightside classic slim dog collar by Holly&Lil

brightside .jpg
  • Best: Boho chic dog collar
  • Sizes: 10.5in to 20in
  • Materials: Cow leather
  • Colourways: Turquoise, orange, pink, red, lime
  • Why we love it
    • Faux-fur finish
  • Take note
    • No additional layer of soft material on the inside

We love the faux-fur effect of this eye-wateringly bright dog collar, which comes with a cute heart-shaped pendant bearing the brand’s logo. Although there isn’t an additional layer of extra-soft material on the inside, the buttery soft feel of the leather means there’s no chance of chafing. The five generously sized buckle holes ensure there’s plenty of room for adjustment, too.

Back to top

Holland Cooper HC classic dog collar

holland cooper .jpg
  • Best: Dog collar for posh pooches
  • Sizes: Medium or Large
  • Materials: Leather, faux pony skin, gold metal hardware
  • Colourways: Chestnut and tweed, black and leopard
  • Why we love it
    • Very luxe
  • Take note
    • Expensive

This leopard-print collar, designed for medium to large dogs, is a great option for mutts who like to take a walk on the wild side. Yes, it’s expensive, but if you’re the owner of a seriously posh pooch, a cheap nylon collar is unlikely to cut it. In short, with its gold buckle and use of genuine leather, it looks and feels like the kind of collar one of the royal corgis would wear.

It’s practical, too, with six holes for size adjustment and an accompanying leaflet providing detailed care instructions. There’s no additional patch of material on the inside of the collar, but this is another one made with leather of such softness that it’s simply not needed.

Back to top

3 Peaks lightweight mesh dog collar small/medium

3 peaks collar .jpg
  • Best: Dog collar for durability
  • Sizes: XS-S, S-M, L-XL
  • Materials: Breathable mesh fabric
  • Colourways: Black and yellow
  • Why we love it
    • Reflective trim for visibility
    • ID barrel for your dog’s details

If practicality is a priority, it’s hard to beat this collar, which has an ultra-bright reflective trim for better visibility on night-time walkies, and is made from a lightweight, breathable material for maximum comfort on long walks.

There’s an ID barrel, in which your dog’s details can be placed, and the sturdy D-ring means your dog – not your lead – will be the one to go walkabout.

Back to top

Wainwright's luxurious woven herringbone dog collar, ink blue

Wainwright .jpg
  • Best: Dog collar for classic style
  • Sizes: XS, S, M, L
  • Materials: N/A
  • Colourways: Ink blue
  • Why we love it
    • Good value for money

As much as we’d love to kit our doggies out in designer gear, doing so isn’t cheap, which is why we’re particularly impressed with this beautiful dog collar. With a gorgeous herringbone design on the outside and buttery soft leather on the inside, it’s a collar that combines comfort with style, and the combination of four sizes and five buckle holes makes this collar perfect for dogs of all shapes and sizes.

Back to top

Dog collars FAQs

What’s the best way to clean a dog collar?

Even if your pet hasn’t been out on a muddy dog walk or spent the day swimming in the sea, the collar it wears will eventually absorb enough skin oils, dirt and grime to warrant a thorough clean. But every collar is different and, as such, needs to be cleaned according to the material from which it is made, whether that’s leather or synthetic.

While some brands will state whether a synthetic collar is machine washable, it’s best to clean by hand if you’re unsure. Simply put a little dog shampoo into a bowl of hot water and soak the collar for 10 to 20 minutes before giving it a light scrubbing – paying special attention to any crevices where dirt and grime can hide. Rinse the collar under warm water, then place it on a flat surface or hang it by the buckle to dry.

When it comes to leather collars, some can be cleaned as described above but others fair less well if they are soaked in water. If you prefer to err on the side of caution, use a little saddle soap on a cloth and scrub the collar clean, wiping away any additional soap and letting the collar air dry away from direct sun, as this can cause cracks. Check the collar’s tag for specific cleaning instructions and warnings.

The verdict: Dog collars

We loved the Joules coastal collar, simply because it gets everything right – it’s stylish and practical, and comes in a wide range of sizes, with plenty of room for adjustment. We also loved the tough-but-breathable material of Walk & Wear’s collar, while Stocky & Dee’s rainbow handmade dog collar is a beautiful accessory with added feel-good factor.

Looking for ways to keep your pooch entertained? Check out our guide to the best dog toys to banish boredom

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in