The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

8 best toasters for the perfect slice, tried and tested

Breakfast is the most important meal of the day, so, start yours with one of these top toasters

Rachael Penn
Tuesday 13 August 2024 06:05 EDT
How do you like your bread in the morning? We’ll take ours toasted
How do you like your bread in the morning? We’ll take ours toasted (The Independent/iStock)
Our Top Picks

There is nothing better than warm, buttery toast, whether it’s for breakfast or a snack throughout the day. If you’re going to have the perfect slice though, you’ll need a decent toaster to make it happen.

A toaster is a staple of any kitchen, and there’s a whole host of different styles on the market, each boasting features that can change your toast game. From basic two-slice toasters to high-end appliances with more buttons and dials than a spaceship, choosing the right one for you could be a trickier task than it appears at first.

But fear not, as we’ve done all the hard work for you and rounded up some of the best toasters on the market, testing them thoroughly to assess how well they perform, how easy they are to use and their whether they offer good value.

As well as looking for toasters that just toast, we’ve also included options that come with a range of functions, such as defrost and reheat.

With models to suit all cooking styles and budgets, keep scrolling for our full guide to the best toasters – we think it’s the best thing since sliced bread.

How we tested

Our tester went several rounds (of toast) with a range of models, to see which toasters came out on top
Our tester went several rounds (of toast) with a range of models, to see which toasters came out on top (The Independent/Rachael Penn)

We put all the toasters featured in this guide through their paces. We looked at how evenly the bread toasted, how long it took to cook and how big a slice the toasters could handle. 

Aesthetics was something else we considered, since most people have their toaster on display at all times. Of course, being carb lovers, we also tried the toaster out with other break-like goodies, including crumpets and bagels. Here are the toasters that performed the best.

The best toasters for 2024 are:

  • Best overall – Ninja foodi three-in-one toaster grill and panini press: £129, Amazon.co.uk
  • Best two-slice toaster – Swan Nordic two-slice toaster: £44.95 (£42.70 with exclusive discount), Hartsofstur.com
  • Best retro toaster - Tower renaissance four-slice toaster: £59.95 (£56.95 with exclusive discount), Hartsofstur.com
  • Best budget buy – Status two-slice toaster: £16.95, Bigonelectricals.co.uk
  • Best four-slice toaster – Delonghi micalite CTOM4003 four-slice toaster: £114.99, Currys.co.uk
  • Best for families – Salter Toronto four-slice toaster: £49.99, Amazon.co.uk

Ninja foodi three-in-one toaster grill and panini press

Ninja best toasters review indybest
  • Best: Overall
  • Number of slices: Two
  • Why we love it
    • Multi-functional
    • Easy to store
    • Works quickly
    • Seven settings
  • Take note
    • The tray sometimes pops out easily
    • Larger than the average toaster

This space-saving toaster also has a grill and panini press function, making it a versatile kitchen companion. If you love sourdough or other toasting bread, you’ll love how easily long slices fit into this toaster. It has seven settings, to ensure you get your preferred crispness, while the grill function is ideal for open-faced sandwiches and quick snacks. The controls are all labelled and easy to use, and the handy timer shows a countdown on the top. Plus, when your toast is done, the toaster has an automatic shut-off feature and will make a noise, so you know your food is ready.

Back to top

Status two-slice toaster

Status best toasters review indybest
  • Best: Budget buy
  • Number of slices: Two
  • Why we love it
    • Small
    • Compact
    • Variable browning function
  • Take note
    • Smells when in operation
    • Feels flimsy

If you have a camper van or caravan, this small, compact toaster from Status is ideal. It’s not the most robust toaster but it has a variable browning control with seven settings and a removal crumb tray, so you can keep it clean. Despite its stainless steel exterior, it stays pretty cool even when in use. It didn’t fit a whole slice of regular shop-bought white bread but it will handle slices from smaller loaves perfectly.

Back to top

Delonghi micalite CTOM4003 four-slice toaster

Delonghi best toasters review indybest
  • Best: Four-slice toaster
  • Number of slices: Four
  • Why we love it
    • Defrost function
    • High-lift eject
    • Extra-wide slots
  • Take note
    • Gets hot to the touch during use

This super stylish and efficient toaster adds a touch of class to any kitchen. It has multiple functions, including defrost, bagel and warm-up, so it’s a good all-rounder and perfect for almost any breakfast situation. It has large slots and each side works independently, so, if you like your toast a little more done than someone else in your household, you can easily set up different settings at once. Getting the toast and other smaller items out of the toaster was also easy, as this model has a high-lift eject. It also has a removable crumb tray, for easy cleaning. This is a solid toaster that will last you for years to come.

Back to top

Swan Nordic two-slice toaster

Swan best toasters review indybest
  • Best: Two-slice toaster
  • Number of slices: Two
  • Why we love it
    • Gorgeous design
    • Simple to use
    • Easy to clean
  • Take note
    • Not many functions

This toaster is so stylish, you’ll end up giving it pride of place on your countertop. It has a Scandinavian-inspired design, with rubberised wood-effect controls that are easy to use. This toaster has three functions: toast, reheat and defrost. It also has six power settings, to ensure your toast is just how you like it. Cleaning is a breeze, too, with a removable crumb tray that just pops out and slots back in. This toaster fits standard-sized slices of bread, and we found they browned quickly. Plus, it has an auto-electric cut-off, for extra safety.

Back to top

Laura Ashley four-slice toaster

Laura Ashley best toasters review indybest
  • Best: For design
  • Number of slices: Four
  • Why we love it
    • Easy to use dials
    • Auto-centring feature
  • Take note
    • It’s light, so could get dented easily

If you’re looking for a toaster that will produce the perfect slice of toast and look good while doing it, look no further. This four-slice toaster has seven heat settings, so you can get your perfect level of toasting. It also has an auto-centring feature, meaning it’ll toast your bread evenly, whether you’ve opted for thick or thin slices. There’s a warming rack, too, so you can keep croissants toasty. This model also features a defrost function (which works really quickly) and a reheat function. Overall, it’s a practical and stylish pick.

Back to top

Salter Toronto four-slice toaster

Salter best toasters review indybest
  • Best: For families
  • Number of slices: Four
  • Why we love it
    • Able to handle larger slices of bread
    • Stylish
    • Easy to operate
  • Take note
    • Controls don’t feel as high-end as the rest of the toaster

If you want a toaster you can rely on to feed the whole family each morning, the Toronto four-slice toaster from Salter should be top of your list. This toaster did a great job of quickly and evenly toasting bread. Each side of the toaster is operated separately, so you can set each to different browning levels, of which there are six.

This toaster also feels really solid and is so well made, the only thing that lets it down is that the controls don’t feel as high-end as the rest of it. It comes in a choice of black or white, has reheat and defrost functions, plus there’s a cancel button, if you want to stop toasting halfway through.

Back to top

Tower renaissance four-slice toaster

Tower best toasters review indybest
  • Best: Retro toaster
  • Number of slices: Four
  • Why we love it
    • Easy to use, with intuitive controls
    • Self-centring function
    • High-lift lever for safe removal of smaller items
  • Take note
    • Outer housing can get hot when in use

This toaster makes for a stylish and functional addition to any kitchen. Our toast came out perfect every time, thanks to the self-centring function. If you are toasting smaller items, this model’s high-lift lever means you can raise them up to retrieve them with ease. There are six different browning levels, and this toaster works really well with both thin and thick slices of bread. As well as being able to operate each side individually, it also has two separate crumb trays, for easier cleaning.

Back to top

ProCook stainless steel toaster

ProCook best toasters review indybest
  • Best: Heavy-duty toaster
  • Number of slices: Four
  • Why we love it
    • Large buttons
    • Variable browning control
  • Take note
    • Fingerprint marks show easily

If you’re looking for a toaster that will stand the test of time, this stainless steel model from ProCook is up for the job. Its sleek and modern design looks good in any kitchen, and it has large buttons that are easy to operate, making it super user-friendly, too. This toaster also has variable browning control with seven settings; extra-wide slots, which will fit standard bread, bagels or thick artisan bread; and defrost, reheat and mid-cycle cancel functions. The toaster does get a little hot when in use but it produces evenly toasted bread time after time.

Back to top

The verdict: Toasters

We love the Ninja three-in-one foodi, which can be used as a grill or panini press as well as delivering your morning round of toast. It’s really easy to use and, given all the functions, we think it offers good value for money.

We’re also super impressed by the ProCook four-slice toaster, which boasts an impressive design and its four slots are perfect for ensuring everyone is fed at once. If you’re on a tighter budget, the Swan Nordic design is fantastic value and works really well, delivering crisp, even toast every time.

For more must-have kitchen appliances, check out our round-up of the best blenders for smoothies and more

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in