The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

Best charcoal for BBQs 2023, tried and tested for summer grilling

From flavouring to burn time, these BBQ charcoals really could take the heat

Alicia Miller
Thursday 08 June 2023 05:18 EDT
Think of it as an ingredient that can inject an enticing smokiness to your food
Think of it as an ingredient that can inject an enticing smokiness to your food (The Independent)
Our Top Picks

Something every pro pitmaster will tell you is that charcoal matters – when it comes to firing up the barbecue this summer and beyond, the best cookouts will always start with the best fuel.

You can spend months agonising over which barbecue to choose, hours over the marinades and dipping sauces you use along with the meat or veggie protein you’ve very carefully selected, but should you opt for some less than fantastic charcoal, your al fresco spread may come up short.

Despite charcoal being an afterthought for many home grillers, it’s one of the biggest factors effecting how your food turns out, affecting everything from the final flavour of your dish to the time you’ll spend cooking.

You need to think of charcoal as an ingredient. After all, it is literally flavouring your food. Top-quality charcoal adds gentle, natural, enticing smokiness to your food – never a synthetic, acrid or burnt taste. That’s just one reason why the best charcoal tends to be made of natural, additive-free lumpwood.

The best also performs well. It is easy to light with natural fire starters (forget lighter fluids – they can impart some unusual, and by that we mean yucky, flavours), and burns consistently. Some of our favourite barbecue charcoal comes in large chunks and can smoulder for many hours – perfect for cooking ribs, brisket or pulled pork. It’s incredibly efficient, which also makes it incredibly good value.

How we tested

When testing, we looked for brands that were produced responsibly. We awarded extra marks to companies that use natural, traceable wood and mindful production methods. Thankfully, there is now more and more of this charcoal on the market, and while it does usually cost a bit more, you can feel good about buying it.

We tested each charcoal across a range of barbecues, from a traditional kettle-style Weber (£219.99, Weber.com) to kamado-style ‘cues like Big Green Egg (£1,375, Biggreenegg.co.uk) and Kamado Joe (£899, Amazon.co.uk). Both meat and veg were prepared, with delicious results. Our favourites? The red-hot options listed below…

The best barbecue charcoal for 2023 are:

The Green Olive Firewood Co premium professional lumpwood charcoal

The Green Olive Firewood Co premium professional lumpwood charcoal indybest.jpg
  • Best: Overall
  • Bag size: 10kg

We can’t get enough of this British charcoal. Not only is it top quality, with (frankly enormous) chunks that burn cleanly for absolutely ages, it’s amazing value. You can bag a full 12kg for the same price that many other charcoal brands on this list charge for just 8kg. If you’re a regular barbecuer or have an especially large grill to fill, the difference in price quickly adds up.

And yet, despite the savings, you’re not compromising. You can use this lumpwood charcoal for all kinds of occasions – grilling, smoking, slow-cooking, even barbecue-style baking. It’s made with sustainable hardwoods such as oak and beech, all ethically sourced from the West Sussex area. And if you have the storage space, you can buy it in bulk – as many as 10 bags in one order – for a discount that drops the cost down to the equivalent of £1.63 per kg. No wonder it’s such a popular pick with restaurant kitchens.

Back to top

Big Green Egg 100% natural oak and hickory lump charcoal

Big Green Egg 100% natural oak and hickory lump charcoal indybest.jpg
  • Best: For Big Green Egg owners
  • Bag size: 8kg

If you’re into your barbecuing, you’ll have heard about Big Green Egg – the kamado-style ceramic ‘cue that’s part master grilling machine, part oven-style slow-cooker. These premium charcoal barbecues are brilliant at delivering flavourful food, partly because the ceramic interior absorbs charcoal smoke character over time. With each new cook, the barbecue itself is basically seasoning your food. Think of it as the equivalent to a cast iron pan.

Because you want good flavour infused in your ceramic, you want to use great quality charcoal – and that’s where this Big Green Egg’s stalwart comes in. It’s made from varied chunks of American oak and hickory hardwood, giving you characterful taste without toxins or accelerants. We love how easily this charcoal lights – and also how long it can burn for (we’ve done countless slow-cooked pork shoulders or lamb legs on just a few large handfuls of the stuff). It might be made for the Big Green Egg, but we’ve also used it in everything from portable open models to kettle-style grills, always with reliable results.

Back to top

Kamado Joe big block XL lump charcoal

Kamado Joe big block XL lump charcoal indybest.jpg
  • Best: For Kamado Joe owners
  • Bag size: 9.1kg

It’s Big Green Egg’s biggest competitor, and it’s easy to see why. The bright red-domed Kamado Joe is seriously impressive – we even love its portable Joe Junior (£499, Bbqworld.co.uk), which was one of our best portable barbecues of 2022. And, unsurprisingly, the brand’s charcoal doesn’t disappoint either.

The brand calls it “big block” and it really means it – our bag was packed with seriously hefty chunks. It’s big on results, too, as it imparted impeccable flavour on our food and burnt for crazy-long periods (Kamado Joe claims it can do 18 hours). The charcoal itself is a blend of dense, exotic hardwoods – Guayacan, Guayaibi, Mistal and White Quebracho – all created by Argentinian charcoal pros in traditional outdoor ovens. The resulting fuel burns clean and consistently, and in our experience works with everything from burgers to a whole roast chicken. You don’t need to reserve it just for Kamado Joes, either – it worked just as well in our kettle-style grill too.

Back to top

Big Green Egg 100% natural Canadian maple lumpwood charcoal

Big Green Egg 100% natural Canadian maple lumpwood charcoal indybest.jpg
  • Best: Maple charcoal
  • Bag size: 8kg

You can probably guess that different types of wood burn differently – and the same goes for when those woods are turned into charcoal. Enter, Big Green Egg’s maple variation. In our experience, this one burns a little bit hotter than the brand’s oak and hickory blend (£28, Biggreenegg.co.uk), and comes with a notably smoothe, sweet, crowd-pleasing charcoal flavour.

It’s hard to pinpoint exactly why, but on balance, of all of Big Green Egg’s excellent fuel offerings, it’s our favourite. Perhaps it’s the large, easy-to-light chunks – sourced only from trusted plantations – or that the charcoal truly burns for ages. Or maybe it’s that it produces minimal ash, making for less clean-up when the barbecue session is over. Whatever the reason, it’s an option not to be overlooked.

Back to top

Masterbuilt lump charcoal

Masterbuilt lump charcoal indybest.jpg
  • Best: For smoking
  • Bag size: 16lbs

This hardwood lump charcoal is designed to be sold with the Masterbuilt gravity series of barbecues – a combined charcoal grill and smoker where low-temperature cooking is as much the point as high. We don’t have one of those, but no matter, we found this charcoal to be a solid performer in our standard Weber kettle-style ‘cue. Expect a good, consistent burn perfect for burgers and skewers, as well as smoking. It doesn’t come with quite the same elaborate story as some other charcoals – though it is made in Mexico using artisan-style kilns – but like all the 100 per cent hardwood options on this list, it’s easy to light and notably efficient.

Back to top

Whittle and Flame ash charcoal

Whittle and Flame ash charcoal indybest.jpg
  • Best: For single species variety
  • Bag size: 4kg

When it comes to boutique British charcoal brands, Whittle and Flame seriously impresses. Founders Matt and Chris don’t just know and love barbecues, the brand cares about making top-quality charcoal in the most environmentally friendly way possible. Using hand-felled British trees – sourced five miles from its location on Cornbury Park – the company makes its charcoal in a unique process called “thermal destructive distillation”. Basically that means preserving the tree’s original carbon structure when it turns to charcoal, and therefore, theoretically, its unique properties and flavours.

As a result, this ash charcoal comes with plenty of character. It lights easily and burns nice and hot, bestowing a lightly smoky flavour to your food. But Whittle and Flame make plenty of other varieties too – lime, sycamore, wild cherry, field maple and oak included. Because the bags are on the smaller side of 4kg, you can easily order a few different charcoal varieties to sample. Alternatively, that compact nature also suits barbecuers with limited storage space.

Back to top

Slate Hill alder charcoal

Slate Hill alder charcoal indybest.jpg
  • Best: For speedy grilling
  • Bag size: 1k

Family-owned newbie Slate Hill makes all its charcoal in Wiltshire, from single species wood sourced in Britain. The star of the range? This unique alder charcoal. Super light and consistently hot burning, its perfect for flash grilling steaks and burgers or adding a gentle sweet smokiness to fish.

Alder trees have been used as charcoal for centuries, and grow quickly, making them among the most sustainable options for charcoal production. Speaking of which, Slate Hill is a major champion, and is committed to producing a fully traceable charcoal. In fact, the brand is so open about how it works, that it’ll even give you a tour of its production process if you’re in the area. Part of its business promise is to use only British deciduous hardwoods – ideally harvested on a coppice rotation – and to process the charcoal using the efficient “retort” method. Even Slate Hill’s packaging, a two-ply brown kraft paper bag, has been designed with a minimal environmental footprint in mind.

Back to top

Big K restaurant charcoal

Big K restaurant charcoal indybest.jpg
  • Best: Bargain
  • Bag size: 15kg

Want good-quality charcoal but can’t justify paying upwards of £2 per kg? This is an excellent go-to. While it doesn’t have quite the lengthy burn time as some of the others on this list – it guarantees two hours rather than the double-digits of some brands – unless you are planning on slow-cooking something for hours on end, it will more than get the job done. The charcoal is still made from hardwood, burns hot and is fairly easy to light. Keep it to hand for those big gatherings where you’re sticking to crowd-pleasing burgers and sausages, where the smoky flavour is the supporting act rather than the star.

Back to top

The verdict: Barbecue charcoal

For a charcoal that balances consistently great quality, sustainable sourcing and a friendly price point, we can’t get enough of The Green Olive Firewood Co premium professional lumpwood charcoal.

When it comes to the established barbecue brands, it’s a toss up between Kamado Joe big block XL lump charcoal and Big Green Egg 100% natural Canadian maple lumpwood charcoal – both come with exceptionally long burn times and have never failed to deliver us quality results.

Finally, if you’re interested in experimenting with single variety wood charcoals, give Whittle and Flame a go. You’ll quickly come to see that charcoal is so much more than fuel – it’s the crucial ingredient in your best-ever barbecue.

Why not spice up your cooking over flames with our round-up of the best hot sauces

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in