The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

I’m a music editor and these are the headphones I recommend

As someone who listens to a lot of music, I think these cans are actually worth your money

Roisin O'Connor
Thursday 16 May 2024 13:05 EDT
Sound quality, noise-cancelling and any other bells and whistles were all on my radar
Sound quality, noise-cancelling and any other bells and whistles were all on my radar (The Independent)
Our Top Picks

Much of my daily life is soundtracked by music. I have a song that wakes me up in the morning, and a playlist I sing along to while I’m trying to wake up and get ready for work. I’m listening to music when I commute into the office, or when I manage to get out for an early morning walk before I sit down at my desk at home. I listen to music on headphones in the office, then I go to gigs, or blast something through my speakers at home to unwind.

Due to the sheer amount of time I spend listening to music, headphones aren’t just a luxury – they’re a necessity. I’m not going to pretend to know lots about the more technical side of headphones. Provided there’s a minimum of 24-hours battery life to the wireless pairs, that suits me just fine. I don’t need (or want) to be faffing around with apps that promise to drastically alter the listening experience, as long as I spend hours fiddling around with different settings. They should be great from the get-go: plug in and play.

My main concerns are how good the sound is and how comfortable they feel – even after long periods of use.

With all that in mind, I’ve rounded-up some of my favourite pairs – both in-ear and over-ear – that I’ve taken for a spin in recent months. I’ve looked at a range of price points, from the super affordable to the higher end of the market, and also took into account the vast array of styles on offer.

Used at home, in the office and during the commute, the cans were tested in a range of different scenarios – keep reading to find out how they fared.

How we tested the headphones

To ensure each brand got a fighting chance, I spent at least a few weeks, if not a month, taking each pair of headphones for a proper spin. If the headphones offered noise-cancelling capabilities, I’d try them out in a number of challenging scenarios, such as a blustery walk along the coast, a noisy train out of London at the end of the working day, and a busy open-plan office. I also tried them out while walking to the train station each morning, and at home while listening to albums on vinyl and connected to speakers or my laptop.

I tried each pair for at least a couple of weeks
I tried each pair for at least a couple of weeks (Roisin O’connor)

Headphones from established and lesser-known brands were put to the test. While reviewing each pair, I compared everything from fit and comfort to the quality of materials used, portability and, of course, sound. Taking different budgets into account, I also made sure to establish whether pricier models were actually worth the money – for that extra £200, I’d expect exceptional sound, with the perfect balance between bass, mid-range and high notes, rich definition and all the bells and whistles.

As a music critic, the headphones I recommend for 2024 are:

  • Best headphones overall – Sennheiser momentum 4 wireless: £269.99, Amazon.co.uk
  • Best budget headphones – Marshall Major IV wireless Bluetooth headphones: £78.97, Amazon.co.uk
  • Best noise-cancelling headphones – Bose quietcomfort ultra wireless noise cancelling headphones with spatial audio: £449, Amazon.co.uk
  • Best in-ear headphones – Sennheiser CX plus true wireless earbuds: £99.95, Amazon.co.uk

Sennheiser momentum 4 wireless

Sennheiser momentum 4 wireless
  • Best: Headphones overall
  • Type: Over-ear
  • Noise-cancellation: Yes
  • Battery life: 60-hours
  • Why we love it
    • Straightforward app
  • Take note
    • Design may be a little too simple for some

I’m a sucker for Sennheiser – the brand’s headphones tick all my boxes in terms of style and sound. The momentum 4s put my loyalty to the test, however, with their simple (harsher critics might say “boring”) design, which goes for the kind of plain white and grey look you’d associate more with Beats or Airpods max (there are other colour options available, including denim-blue).

Still, Sennheiser remains hard to beat when it comes to sound quality – even more so if you’re technologically adept enough to play with the brand’s Smart Control app, which enables you to adjust active noise cancelling (ANC), select a preferred sound (A, B or C), or even pick when specific preferences (such as noise isolation levels) kick in, depending on if you’re entering your office building or leaving the house. Pretty impressive.

For the technologically fearful (the app is actually very straightforward), these babies still come with a cable (though, you should try out the 60-hour battery life) and a conveniently slim fabric hardshell case.

Songs I enjoyed with the Sennheiser momentum 4 wireless included “Crystal Tears” by Elmiene, “awe” by Pem and “I Guess” by Lizzy McAlpine.

Back to top

Marshall major IV wireless Bluetooth headphones

best headphones Marshall Major IV wireless Bluetooth headphones
  • Best: Budget headphones
  • Type: On-ear
  • Noise cancellation: Yes
  • Battery life: 80+ hours
  • Why we love it
    • Small but mighty
    • Good quality for the price

These dinky cans from one of the most respected music brands around are an absolute bargain. They’re extremely compact and lightweight but also highly durable, thanks to the reinforced rubber dampers and faux-leather headband.

Small but mighty, Marshall’s major IV pair boasts 80+ hours of wireless playing time (I tried, I tested, I triumphed), and their ergonomic design means they’re still comfortable by the fifth or even 15th hour (maybe give your ears a rest before then, though).

Meanwhile, the multi-directional knob is a nice change from touch-sensitive controls, and feels more like you’re operating one of Marshall’s classic amps. Marshall loves rock ’n’ roll, so, expect a good thump on the bass and plenty of oomph everywhere else. Overall, you get a lovely resonance to the sound and a quality that feels remarkable for the price.

Songs I enjoyed on the Marshall Major IV wireless included “I Love Rock ‘N Roll” by Joan Jett, “Edge of Seventeen” by Stevie Nicks, and “Nutbush City Limits” by Tina Turner.

Back to top

Bose quietcomfort ultra wireless noise cancelling headphones with spatial audio

best headphones Bose QuietComfort ultra wireless noise cancelling headphones with spatial audio
  • Best: Noise-cancelling headphones
  • Type: Over-ear
  • Noise cancellation: Yes
  • Battery life: Up to 24-hours
  • Why we love it
    • Very comfortable
    • Responsive
  • Take note
    • Expensive

At the very top end of the price bracket comes the Bose quietcomfort ultras. Yes, they’re hardly cheap but, once you slip them on, you’ll realise they’re worth every penny.

First, let’s talk about the comfort: these are by far the most agreeable pair I’ve tried. In fact, I could barely tell I was wearing them. They’re incredibly light and suitable for wearing for long periods of time – they’re great for long-haul flights as well as the daily commute. The plastic earcups and headband have a smart matte finish, and are connected by solid aluminium hinges that rotate smoothly and enable them to fit into their extraordinarily compact hard-shell carrying case.

In terms of sound quality, these are second to none. I love the resonance you get, especially when listening to bass-heavy R&B or hip-hop tracks. They’re also amazingly responsive – flitting between tracks spanning all manner of genres does nothing to dent the sound experience. If you’re looking for a particularly immersive experience, you can’t do better. Switch on the active noise cancellation and prepare to be transported.

Songs I enjoyed listening to with the Bose quietcomfort ultra wireless included “People” by Libianca, “Kill Bill” by SZA and “Hey Mami” by Sylvan Esso.

Back to top

Meze 99 classics

best headphones Meze 99 classics
  • Best: Headphones for sound quality
  • Type: Over-ear
  • Noise cancellation: No
  • Battery life: N/A
  • Why we love it
    • Super stylish
    • Great balance
  • Take note
    • Bass could be better

I hadn’t heard of Meze until I started looking around at different headphone brands, but I was enchanted by the striking design of its 99 classics. This pair isn’t Bluetooth compatible but it’s ideal for home or studio use, whether you want to plug them into your laptop, speakers or record player, and will also work with a phone that has a headphone jack.

The cans come in a smart, felt-lined leatherette hardcase bearing a classy black and gold metal button with the Meze logo, along with two cables of varying lengths, a quarter-inch jack and a plane adaptor.

The headphones themselves are gorgeous – matte walnut earcups (there are different colour options) with buttery soft protein leather earpads complemented perfectly by gold accents. The sleek and stylish cans are completed with two black running rails over the imitation-leather headband.

The sound is excellent, and you’ll find yourself falling down a rabbit hole of music just to see how it sounds with the 99 classics. There’s a great balance between the highs, lows and midrange (the bass isn’t outstanding, but still pretty good), and even the most auto-tuned of pop stars seems to gain an added grit to their vocals, thanks to these cans.

Songs I enjoyed with the 99 classics included “Cardinal” by Kacey Musgraves, “Gears” by Divorce, “Stand Tall” by Rapsody and “Oh Well” by Caity Baser.

Back to top

Sony WF-1000XM5 wireless noise cancelling headphones

best headphones Sony WF-1000XM5 wireless noise cancelling headphones
  • Best: For the commute
  • Type: In-ear
  • Noise cancellation: Yes
  • Battery life: Up to 24-hours
  • Why we love it
    • Super discreet
    • Sparkling sound
  • Take note
    • ANC could be better
    • Not the most comfortable

Sony’s smart pair of in-ears are super discreet in their little pebble case, and the earbuds are tiny as well, with strong magnets that make sure they stay securely in their case until you need them.

While I was a little iffy about the price, considering they’re in-ears, the sound is sparkling clean with little to no distortion. There was also no discernible drop in quality while using the ANC, although, it’s not the best I’ve tried – it can just about cover a strong breeze or the buzz of traffic. Meanwhile, there’s a pleasing punch to the bass, and vocals stand out wonderfully against the instrumentation.

In terms of comfort, I didn’t get on as well with these ones as with other in-ears. To create a “seal”, it felt as though they needed to be pushed relatively far into the ear, which soon became uncomfortable, making them less suitable for longer periods of use. The earbuds themselves are also incredibly sensitive, meaning, on occasions, it seemed like even my hair brushing against them managed to pause or skip a track.

Songs I enjoyed listening to on the Sony WF-1000XM5 wireless included “Like a Prayer” by Madonna, “Motivation” by Normani and “The Passenger” by Iggy Pop.

Back to top

Bower and Wilkins PX7 S2

best headphones Bower and Wilkins PX7 S2
  • Best: For design
  • Type: Over-ear
  • Noise cancellation: Yes
  • Battery life: 30-hours
  • Why we love it
    • Sleek design
    • Super comfy
    • Bass packs a punch
  • Take note
    • Expensive

Sitting near the top end of our price bracket is the Bower and Wilkins PX7 S2, with their sleek redesign that offers a suitably more upmarket look, compared with some of the other models out there. I love the metallic accents between the shell and the memory foam cups (super comfy, by the way, fitting snugly over my ears), and the moisture-repellent fabric over the headband that matches the hard material case.

The bass really packs a punch here, thanks, in part, to the angled drivers that also offer a greater sense of intimacy on the vocals. It also picks out all the details, from the subtle vibrations on the strum of a guitar to the brassy parp of a saxophone. Perfect if you want substance to match your sense of style.

Songs I enjoyed listening to on the Bowers and Wilkins PX7 S2s included “Body Was Made” by Ezra Furman, “I Don’t Want to Know” by Fleetwood Mac, and “California Dreamin’” by The Mamas & The Papas.

Back to top

Sennheiser CX plus true wireless earbuds

best headphones Sennheiser CX plus true wireless earbuds
  • Best: In-ear headphones
  • Type: In-ear
  • Noise cancellation: Yes
  • Battery life: 24-hour
  • Why we love it
    • Comfortable
    • Good battery life
    • IPX4 splash-resistant

This is an ideal pair for when you’re out and about and don’t fancy carting a more cumbersome (and expensive) set of over-ear headphones with you. Sennheiser’s CX plus true wireless earbuds are compact, comfortable and don’t compromise on quality. I’ve had mine for more than a year and still find myself impressed by the battery life – rarely have I been caught needing to charge them mid-journey.

The buds come with a range of ear adaptor sizes, and you can customise them through Sennheiser’s Smart Control app for iOS/Android, which also lets you to enable smooth pairing, calls and voice assistant. There’s also a pre-set that allows for a more intense bass, although, personally, I enjoy the excellent midrange offered by the CX plus model as standard. Caught in the rain? No problem – these bad boys are IPX4 splash-resistant.

Songs I enjoyed listening to on the Sennheiser CX plus true wireless earbuds included “Training Season” by Dua Lipa, “Down Bad” by Taylor Swift, and “Bodyguard” by Beyoncé.

Back to top

The verdict: Headphones

For an everyday pair that doesn’t compromise on quality, we recommend the Sennheiser CX plus true wireless earbuds. They’ll fit into your pocket or a small bag while still offering fantastic sound, along with effective active noise cancellation. If you’re after a more immersive experience with higher definition sound, as well as something a touch more stylish, we’d splash out on the Bose quietcomfort ultras for a perfect all-rounder that lifts your mood on even the most arduous of journeys. However, Sennheiser remains hard to beat when it comes to sound quality, with the brand’s momentum 4 wireless headphones taking the top spot here.

For more in-ear audio recommendations, read our tech critic’s review of the best earbuds

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in