The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

15 best eye creams and serums to combat dark circles, fine lines, and puffiness

These are the top under-eye formulas for tired peepers

Helen Wilson-Beevers
Thursday 30 May 2024 11:16 EDT
During testing, we looked for key ingredients, as well as texture, skincare results and price point
During testing, we looked for key ingredients, as well as texture, skincare results and price point (The Independent)
Our Top Picks

When it comes to tackling dark circles, fine lines and puffiness, the best eye creams are designed with delicate skin in mind. Their formulas are specifically created for the under-eye area, which can be more prone to irritation and dehydration. As well as addressing issues such as the presence of under-eye bags and crow’s feet, the best eye creams also act as primers underneath concealer and eyeshadow.

Although some eye creams promise to completely banish dark circles, the presence of this under-eye discoloration can be due to an array of reasons, some of which a cream won’t correct, including pigmentation and genetics. Similarly, puffiness might be caused by allergies, fluid retention or the natural ageing process.

So, while eye creams and serums can temporarily help improve the appearance of dark circles, puffiness, and fine lines, they won’t completely eradicate them. Instead, think of eye cream as a skincare step to smooth this area of the face, while offering hydration and radiance, which can counteract the appearance of any concerns.

Key ingredients to look out for include hydrating and brightening hyaluronic acid, peptides, vitamin C, and caffeine, while introducing retinol ingredients can help with skin texture in the long term.

With all this in mind, we’ve been putting a selection of the best eye creams to the test, from lightweight soothing formulas to rich, balms and refreshing serums.

How we tested the best eye creams

We spent months testing a selection of eye creams and serums
We spent months testing a selection of eye creams and serums (The Independent/Helen Wilson-Beevers)

We spent months testing a selection of eye creams and serums said to improve the look of dark circles and fine lines. We looked at the key ingredients included in each product, as well as texture, skincare results and price point. Keep reading for our full verdict on the best eye creams for all budgets.

The best eye creams for 2024 are:

  • Best eye cream overall – Ren brightening dark circle eye cream: £49, boots.com
  • Best budget eye cream – CeraVe reparative eye cream: £9.50, Amazon.co.uk
  • Best moisturising eye cream – Skin Proud secure the barrier barrier-boosting eye cream: £14.95, Iamproud.com
  • Best eye cream for fine lines – Allies of Skin peptides and omegas firming eye cream: £65.60, Spacenk.com
  • Best eye cream for puffiness – Fenty Skin thicc n smooth rich peptide eye cream: £25.60, Boots.com

Ren brightening dark circle eye cream

Ren-eye-creams-indybest
  • Best: Eye cream overall
  • Product size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Hyaluronic acid, elderberry flowers and glycogen
  • Why we love it
    • Mess-free use
    • Eyes look refreshed
    • Vegan formula
    • Layers well with concealer

Presented in a compact bottle with a mess-free pump applicator, this eye cream felt immediately refreshing on our skin. Key ingredients include hydration-promoting hyaluronic acid and brightening and balancing elderberry flower and glycogen. The midweight formula has a slightly glossy sheen, which adds a luxe, silky finish and instantly brightened up the skin around our tired peepers.

This eye cream absorbs well and leaves a lingering layer of radiance on the surface of the skin, which we found temporarily improved the appearance of dark circles. Because of how smoothing this eye cream is, we noted it’s an ideal primer for helping concealers stay put, too.

  1.  £49 from boots.com
Prices may vary
Back to top

CeraVe reparative eye cream

best eye creams for dark circles bags wrinkles and puffiness uk 2023
  • Best: Budget eye cream
  • Product size: 14ml
  • Key ingredients: Ceramides and hydrating hyaluronic acid
  • Why we love it
    • Protects skin’s natural barrier
    • Lightweight lotion
    • Hydrating

A gentle eye cream, this formula is enriched with skin-barrier-protecting ceramides and has a soothing salve-style formula. It’s fragrance-free and non-comedogenic, so the cream is suitable for sensitive skin and won’t block pores for those prone to blemishes, either.

The ingredients meant this product left our skin feeling gently moisturised, with hyaluronic acid in there to draw hydration to the surface, too. It’s a no-frills budget buy that offers moisturising benefits, and we grabbed it on days our under-eye area felt dull or dry.

Back to top

Skin Proud secure the barrier barrier-boosting eye cream

Skin-proud-eye-cream-indybest
  • Best: Moisturising eye cream
  • Size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Ceramides, peptides and squalene
  • Why we love it
    • Moisturising
    • A little goes a long way

This purse-friendly tube of eye cream costs £15 and contains ceramides, peptides and squalene for hydration and supporting the skin’s natural barrier. The eye cream feels comforting on skin and has a silky-soft texture.

We noted a little bit of this product went a long way and covered a large amount of the delicate skin around our eyes. While the formula has a midweight richness to it, the eye cream isn’t heavy and instead feels gently enriching. We noticed fine lines looked slightly smoother upon application of this cream.

Back to top

The Ordinary multi-peptide eye serum

best eye creams for dark circles bags wrinkles and puffiness uk 2023
  • Best: Eye serum
  • Product size: 30ml
  • Key ingredients: Peptides, caffeine, acetyl glucosamine, niacinamide and ash-bark extract
  • Why we love it
    • Brightening hydration boost
    • Calms puffiness
    • Good for sensitive skin
    • Lightweight and soothing
  • Take note
    • Serum instead of a cream

If you’re seeking a serum rather than an eye cream, this is a lightweight, cooling option. It’s thanks to key components such as peptides, caffeine and niacinamide that we noted our skin looked brighter and the tone slightly more balanced.

The transparent serum is water-based and soaks into skin rapidly. It doesn’t leave any residue, and we liked how hydrating the multi-tasking formula is for puffiness, fine lines and dry skin.

It’s presented in a recyclable glass bottle, and the pipette dropper applicator enables easy use.

Read our full The Ordinary multi-peptide eye serum review

Back to top

Medik8 crystal retinal ceramide eye (3, 6 or 10)

Medik8-eye-cream-indybest
  • Best: Retinoid eye cream
  • Size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Retinal, hyaluronic acid and ceramides
  • Why we love it
    • Can choose retinal strength to suit

This retinal eye cream is available in three different strengths, so you can shop according to your skin’s sensitivity level. Its main ingredient, retinaldehyde (AKA retinal), targets fine lines and skin texture and is joined by hydrating hyaluronic acid and ceramides, which help protect the barrier.

Due to our sensitive skin, we used this eye cream two to three times a week but it can be applied more often after a fortnight of use. The formula offers a smoothing finish on skin, with a moisturising effect. As with all retinal and retinol products, it will take a while to see the long-term results.

Back to top

Farmacy wake up honey eye cream

Farmacy-eye-creams-indybest
  • Best: Rich eye cream
  • Size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Vitamin C, caffeine, cranberry peptide and honey
  • Why we love it
    • Comforting on skin
    • Moisturising

Boasting an appealing texture – somewhere between a gel and balm – this eye cream feels comforting on skin. We noticed it enriched our delicate under-eye skin with moisture and left a lingering softness that added subtle radiance, too.

Rich but not too cloying or too heavy, the texture of this eye cream delivers welcome hydration, which we saw and felt for several hours. This effect helped our fine lines look a little less noticeable, and the hydrating benefits counteracted any dullness.

Back to top

Allies of Skin peptides and omegas firming eye cream

Peptides-allies-of-skin-eye-cream-indybest
  • Best: Eye cream for fine lines
  • Size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Peptides, vitamin C, bakuchiol
  • Why we love it
    • Smoothing
    • Brightening
  • Take note
    • Pricey

This luxurious eye cream has a glossy finish and immediately added luminous radiance to our skin. The midweight product contains natural retinol alternative bakuchiol, as well as vitamin C, peptides and oils containing omegas. While it’s undeniably a major splurge, we noticed our skin looked brightened and, as a result, dark circles appeared less noticeable after application. We also liked how soft our skin felt after dabbing the cream around our eyes, leaving a visible smoothness. Plus, it has a pump applicator, for hygienic ease.

Back to top

Fenty Skin thicc n smooth rich peptide eye cream

Fenty-skin-eye-cream-indybest
  • Best: Eye cream for puffiness
  • Size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Hyaluronic acid, caffeine, peptides and niacinamide
  • Why we love it
    • Unique twist-up pot
    • Hydrating

What’s unique about this eye cream is its twist-up pot, which has an easy release and has been designed for those with long nails. The cream has an array of hydrating, balancing, and brightening ingredients, including hyaluronic acid, caffeine and niacinamide. We found it calming for puffiness in the morning, too. The texture is buttery-soft, which makes it glide across the delicate under-eye area, and we didn’t see any greasy residue, just a silky-smooth skincare layer. Plus, because of how rich the cream is, a little dab goes a long way.

  1.  £25 from Boots.com
Prices may vary
Back to top

BareMinerals ageless phyto-retinol eye cream

Bare-minerals-eye-cream-indybest
  • Best: Smoothing eye cream
  • Size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Plant-based retinol alternative, peptides, hyaluronic acid
  • Why we love it
    • Softening
    • Lessens fine lines
    • Cooling

This is a midweight white cream that turns into a transparent layer as it’s absorbed, and we found the consistency to be softening on skin. This product contains peptides and hyaluronic acid as well as phyto-retinol, which is a plant-based alternative to the real thing, and less likely to irritate skin. We found it to offer a smoothing layer on skin, creating the illusion of our fine lines being lessened. While it’s richly glossy, the cream also has a welcome cooling feel and helped improve the look of puffiness, too.

Back to top

La Roche-Posay pigmentclar eyes

Pigmentclar-eye-cream-la-roche-posay-indybest
  • Best: Applicator
  • Product size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Niacinamide, shea butter and caffeine
  • Why we love it
    • Cooling applicator
    • Improves puffiness quickly
    • Light and gentle
    • Colour-correcting

Formulated specifically with dark circles in mind, ingredients include niacinamide, shea butter and caffeine. Plus, this tube of eye cream comes complete with a cooling applicator. When we popped the metal tip straight onto our skin, we felt and saw an initial improvement to puffiness. Meanwhile, the midweight hydrating formula itself is light and gentle on skin, which would appeal if you’re not a fan of thick eye creams.

The peach-coloured cream has a correcting element for brightening blue and brown dark circles, and we noted this product did help improve their appearance.

Back to top

No7 protect and perfect intense advanced eye cream

best eye creams for dark circles bags wrinkles and puffiness uk 2023
  • Best: Value eye cream
  • Product size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Shea butter, hyaluronic acid, ginseng extract and an antioxidant complex
  • Why we love it
    • Smoothed fine lines
    • Layers well under make-up
    • Absorbs easily
  • Take note
    • A lot of product comes out at once

This eye cream comes in a tube and has a pointed tip for precise application. The No7 product was created to help with dark circles and puffiness, with an ingredients list that includes shea butter, hyaluronic acid, ginseng extract and an antioxidant complex.

We found the cream subtly smoothed over fine lines, especially ahead of applying make-up. Quite a bit comes out at once, and the lightweight cream is more like a lotion, but it does absorb easily. Skin felt supple and softened after application, thanks to this cream’s lightly moisturising effects.

  1.  £16 from Boots.com
Prices may vary
Back to top

Burt’s Bees 98.9% natural hydrating daily eye cream

best eye creams for dark circles bags wrinkles and puffiness uk 2023
  • Best: Eye cream for sensitive skin
  • Product size: 14.1g
  • Key ingredients: Cotton extract and aloe vera
  • Why we love it
    • Perfect for sensitive skin
    • Smooths and soothes under-eye area

Formulated for sensitive skin, this eye cream contains soothing cotton extract and aloe vera. When we dabbed the glossy, balm-like cream around our eyes, we instantly felt a comforting effect. We also found the cream gradually absorbed after simply dotting it onto skin, so there was no need for rubbing in.

We saw a smooth-looking under-eye area but, most of all, our skin felt significantly soothed. We also like the chunky bottle, complete with a pump applicator and Burt’s Bees logo-emblazoned lid.

Back to top

Mantle the eye smoother

best eye creams for dark circles bags wrinkles and puffiness uk 2023
  • Best: CBD eye cream
  • Product size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: CBD, hyaluronic acid, squalane and vitamin E
  • Why we love it
    • Leaves skin soft and radiant
    • Under-eye area felt super supple
    • Great for early morning puffiness
  • Take note
    • A little pricey

Presented in a white bottle with minimalist branding, this eye cream contains CBD, hyaluronic acid, squalane and vitamin E. This is a midweight formula that has a glossy finish when sliding across skin, and we saw a gentle shine as it soaked in. After the cream absorbed, we had softened skin with an added subtle radiance. Plus, our under-eye area felt supple, and the hydrating cream helped soothe early morning puffiness.

The cream easily smoothed over the skin beneath our fatigued peepers, offering a moisturising layer for tight dryness, too.

Back to top

Skinceuticals eye balm

best eye creams for dark circles bags wrinkles and puffiness uk 2023
  • Best: Eye cream with a thick formula
  • Product size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Aloe vera and vitamin E
  • Why we love it
    • Rich balmy texture
    • Soothes parched skin
    • Extra hydration
    • Glides onto skin
    • A little goes a long way
  • Take note
    • Expensive

What we liked most about this cream is its rich, balmy texture, which feels suitably soothing on parched skin. Created for dry skin, the formula’s ingredients include aloe vera and vitamin E to provide comforting moisture. As such, we saw this extra hydration help combat the appearance of any puffiness.

The softening formula glides onto skin without the need for much rubbing in, which is ideal for the delicate under-eye area. Plus, a tiny bit goes a long way, so, this premium-priced pot should last ages. If you’re looking for an intense hydration boost, this is the eye cream for you.

Back to top

Teoxane R(II) eyes

best eye creams for dark circles bags wrinkles and puffiness uk 2023
  • Best: Cooling eye cream
  • Product size: 15ml
  • Key ingredients: Hyaluronic acid, sunflower-seed oil, glycerin and peptides
  • Why we love it
    • Cooling wand
    • Feels luxurious
    • Improves early morning puffiness
    • Smooths fine lines

This tinted cream contains key ingredients, such as hyaluronic acid, sunflower-seed oil, glycerine and peptides. We pushed down the tall bottle’s pump-release applicator, while pressing the cooling wand tip to our eye area. Application felt luxurious, and our tired eyes appreciated the refreshing relief, which helped improve early morning puffiness, too. We saw a subtle smoothing of fine lines after applying the cream, and gentle illumination to dark circles.

Because it’s tinted, this product is particularly effective on bare-face days, or if you prefer not to wear a lot of make-up.

Back to top

Eye cream FAQs

How is eye cream different from face cream?

Because eye cream is designed to target a smaller area, compared with covering the entire face, it may contain more concentrated ingredients for focusing on concerns, including fine lines and dark circles. Often, key components found in an eye cream formula are exactly the same as those seen in face cream, but they can be much richer for smoothing onto that delicate under-eye area.

Which is better, an eye gel or an eye cream?

An eye gel can feel refreshing on skin, particularly if you pop it in the fridge first, while a comforting creamy formula is often equally soothing. There’s no definitive answer as to which is better – like all beauty buys, it’s simply down to personal preference and skin type.

What to look for in an eye cream

An eye cream’s ingredients list will differ depending on what specific skin concern it’s trying to target. For example, if you’re looking to brighten up dark circles, look for vitamin C and caffeine. Meanwhile, hyaluronic acid promotes hydration and can help if you’re prone to dryness. Additionally, peptides are great for plumping and improving the appearance of fine lines.

What’s the best eye cream for mature skin?

Skin becomes fragile and loses elasticity as it matures, so, opt for ingredients that plump up, hydrate and increase collagen production in the skin. Hyaluronic acid is known for hydration, while antioxidants such as vitamin C and vitamin A can speed up the regeneration of cells. Also look for products with retinol, which exfoliates the skin and ramps up collagen levels, for a smoother complexion.

Do eye creams work?

Although they’re by no means an instant fix, eye creams are designed to improve the appearance of wrinkles and dark circles, and they can also help soothe and repair skin.

When should I start using eye cream?

Most people start using eye cream from their 30s onwards, as this is when fine lines and wrinkles gradually begin to appear more noticeable. There are benefits to be found in using eye cream from your 20s, too – for preventive skincare purposes and to address existing puffiness or dark circles.

How to apply eye cream

As the skin around the eye is thin, delicate and prone to sensitivity, it’s best not to be too heavy-handed when applying product to the area. Use your ring finger to dab the product gently under the eye and around the orbital bone until absorbed, taking care not to tug or pull skin.

The verdict: Eye creams

Our best overall buy is Ren’s brightening dark circle eye cream, thanks to it making the skin around our eyes look more radiant. Meanwhile, CeraVe repair cream is an affordable, gentle, barrier-protecting option to help hydrate even sensitive skin. Finally, The Ordinary’s multi-peptide eye serum is a lightweight option offering a refreshing effect.

Protect your skin from damaging UV rays, with our pick of the best sunscreens for your face

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in