The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

8 best foundation sticks for a flawless finish

Reinvented in lightweight, buildable formulas, complexion sticks have had a glow-up

Elena Chabo
Beauty writer
Friday 27 September 2024 11:10 EDT
Whether you have dry, oily, dehydrated or combination skin, there’s something to suit everybody
Whether you have dry, oily, dehydrated or combination skin, there’s something to suit everybody (The Independent/iStock)
Our Top Picks

In one of beauty’s most unexpected comebacks, brands have been launching foundation sticks left, right and centre, and we’ve been busy searching for the best on offer. Foundation sticks have never been the stars of the beauty world but they had a solid footing in the late 2000s and the 2010s until they got shifted out of the way to make room for shiny new formulas.

While your mind may go straight to heavy, thick, full coverage, some of these new launches are really changing the game, with skin-tint sticks and complexion sticks offering super blendable, lightweight tints and even dewy finishes.

Thanks to their cream stick nature, many work great for contouring and highlighting, too, while another big advantage is how easy they are to pop in your bag, without having to worry about leaks. Watch out, though, as, like other types of make-up, foundation sticks can dry out if exposed to air for too long, so, keep that lid on.

As the popularity of foundation sticks shows no sign of slowing down, we set out to test the best on the market, to find out which are worth making the swap and will have you saying goodbye to your favourite liquid formula.

How we tested

Our expert in action applying the foundation sticks
Our expert in action applying the foundation sticks (Elena Chabo)

We applied each product directly from the bullet to the skin and then experimented with fingers and brushes for blending. We considered how easy the foundation sticks were to use, how blendable the formulas were, what the finish was like, how the product felt on the skin, as well as what level of coverage they offered. We also looked at wear, shade range, value for money and packaging. Keep scrolling to find out which ones impressed us the most.

The best foundation sticks for 2024 are:

  • Best overall – Merit the minimalist complexion perfecting stick: £40, Meritbeauty.com
  • Best budget buy – No7 stay perfect foundation stick: £14.95, No7beauty.co.uk
  • Best for skincare ingredients – Anastasia Beverly Hills beauty balm serum boosted skin tint: £43, Lookfantastic.com
  • Best for a natural matte look – Ilia skin rewind complexion stick: £48, Spacenk.com
  • Best luxury option – Westman Atelier vital skin foundation stick: £62, Spacenk.com

Merit the minimalist complexion perfecting stick

Merit-best-foundation-sticks-review-indybest
  • Best: Overall
  • Shades: 30
  • Size: 6.5g
  • Why we love it
    • Healthy glow
    • Buildable coverage
    • Dimensional shades
  • Take note
    • Small size
    • Have to take care when opening

When first applied, this product looks very ‘foundationy’ but, once it melts in, it literally looks like you’re wearing nothing but flawless skin. If you want glow without a blinding radiance, this is for you. The shades have such beautiful undertones and really bring out the best in your complexion. Pores, fine lines and scarring were all blurred away, with light to medium coverage. The tube was a little hard to use, as the lid has a strong magnetic close, which will keep your product safe but does make it tricky to open without smooshing the stick a little. If it weren’t for that and the small 6.5g size, this foundation stick would have scored full marks.

Back to top

No7 stay perfect foundation stick

No7-best-foundation-sticks-review-indybest
  • Best: Budget buy
  • Shades: 18
  • Size: 8g
  • Why we love it
    • Impressive coverage
  • Take note
    • Limited shade range

At a quarter of the price of most other foundation sticks on the market, this offering from No7 does a fair job for its price. It wasn’t too hard to blend but it did sit on the skin a little, so, make sure to buff it in, to avoid unwanted texture.

Marketed as semi-matte, it gives an almost powder-like look on the skin and has impressive coverage. The brand used Skin Expert tech, analysing 1.9 million skin tones to create the shade range. While we found it to be a great shade match, looking at the swatch photos online, the shade range seems to stop at medium deep, which really lets it down in 2024.

Back to top

Charlotte Tilbury unreal skin sheer glow tint hydrating foundation stick

Charlotte-Tilbury-best-foundation-sticks-review-indybest
  • Best: For a dewy finish
  • Shades: 20
  • Size: 9g
  • Why we love it
    • Luminous glow
    • Filter effect
    • Super lightweight
  • Take note
    • Minimal coverage

Forget everything you thought you knew about foundation sticks, and listen up if you’re into no-make-up-make-up. Upon first swipe, this formula looks almost like a highlighter, and we were a little worried it would be too shimmery but it’s so easy to blend and the glow melts into the most beautiful light-reflecting radiance. Micro-fine pearlescent filters are to thank for this, combined with hydrating vitamin E and hyaluronic acid, melting away imperfections and resulting in skin that looks naturally flawless. Offering sheer to light coverage, this one would need to be paired with a good concealer if you’re looking to completely cover blemishes or scarring. Anything this lightweight isn’t going to last 12 hours, so, after-work top-ups may be needed.

Back to top

Anastasia Beverly Hills beauty balm serum boosted skin tint

Anastasia-best-foundation-sticks-review-indybest
  • Best: For skincare ingredients
  • Shades: 15
  • Size: 18g
  • Why we love it
    • Includes skincare ingredients
    • Easy to use shape
    • Large size
  • Take note
    • Limited shade range
    • High price point

We love the sound of a hydrating serum BB cream in stick form, making it easy to swipe on and go. This product certainly has skincare credentials, coming packed with a peptide complex, fatty acids, collagen stabiliser coconut oil, shea butter and more. Alas, we fell between two shades, with one firmly too light, leaving us looking ashy, and the next too dark, giving us a muddy look. Seeing the product used on people who did have a colour match, it did really even out complexion, without too much coverage, offering a healthy glowy finish. More shades definitely need to be added to the range, however, especially at the deep end.

Back to top

Bobbi Brown skin foundation stick

Bobbi-Brown-best-foundation-sticks-review-indybest
  • Best: Full-coverage foundation
  • Shades: 42
  • Size: 9g
  • Why we love it
    • Wide shade range
    • Long wear
    • High coverage
  • Take note
    • Can settle on dry skin

This buildable, medium to full coverage option really covers everything for a totally flawless look that is still light on the skin and doesn’t look like you’re wearing heavy make-up. It promises a skin-like finish, which we were sceptical of when first applying but, after it settled and had some time to warm up and melt into the skin, it did look pretty natural for full coverage. As the formula a bit thicker, we found we needed to blend with a brush, which made it easier to spread the product over the face, compared with using our fingers. The wear was excellent and it really didn’t budge for hours.

Back to top

Ilia skin rewind complexion stick

Ilia-best-foundation-sticks-review-indybest
  • Best: For a natural matte look
  • Shades: 42
  • Size: 10g
  • Why we love it
    • True to skin shades
    • Anti-ageing ingredients
  • Take note
    • Drags when applying

Due to a slight dragging effect, this product was a little harder to apply directly onto the skin than some of the others we tested. The less-supple formula makes sense, though, given it offers a natural matte coverage. We found this product easier to initially buff and blend with a brush, paying attention to areas such as around the mouth, eyes and nose, where foundations tend to crease. Then the product really benefitted from being worked into the skin with warm fingers. It took a little more work than some of the others but the result was top-tier coverage.

Covering pores, redness and imperfections, this option steers clear of glow, providing more of a softly lit look that doesn’t budge all day. It makes skin look so smooth and soft, too. Looking at shade match videos online, the 42 shade offering has really knocked it out of the park, creating true-to-life skin tones across all complexions.

Back to top

Hourglass seamless finish foundation stick

Hourglass-best-foundation-sticks-review-indybest
  • Best: For full glam
  • Shades: 33
  • Size: 7.2g
  • Why we love it
    • Innovative triangle shape
    • Buttery formula
    • Premium package design
  • Take note
    • Limited deep shades

If you’re looking for a full-coverage base for your full-glam looks, this is for you. The innovative triangle-shaped bullet made precision application so easy – using lighter and deeper shades would be great for contouring. A little of this goes a very long way, too, which makes up for it being on the pricier side for the size. Buffing in with a brush, this formula literally hides everything on the skin, which is great if you’re looking for a flawless start, but does mean it needs to be matched with more of a full-glam look, to balance and bring back dimension. It lasts all day without going patchy or sweating off. Points were lost due to the fact deeper complexions are not well catered for.

Back to top

Westman Atelier vital skin foundation stick

Westman-Atelier-best-foundation-sticks-review-indybest
  • Best: Luxury option
  • Shades: 20
  • Size: 9g
  • Why we love it
    • Super luxe design
    • Soothing ingredients
  • Take note
    • Will settle in dry skin
    • Extremely high price point

This bad boy is pricey. What you’re paying for is the super luxurious packaging and the clean formula – it has antioxidants and calming actives, to soothe redness, as well as camellia oil for glow. It’s a foundation and concealer in one and that’s reflected in the medium to full coverage. It’s recommended to blend in with fingers, after swiping directly onto the skin, but we struggled to get an even application without first using a brush and then using fingers to really pat in the foundation. The formula is creamy and buildable, but we did find it settled into fine lines and pores, so it’s really important to moisturise prior to use and use a good primer, if you have areas that need extra-smoothing.

Back to top

The verdict: Foundation sticks

We’ve been pleasantly surprised by a number of these foundation sticks, however, we found the best all-rounder to be the Merit complexion stick, which has a perfect amount of coverage, while still looking like skin. If you’re after a more matte finish, the Ilia skin rewind complexion stick should be your go-to – think matte but lit from within. Meanwhile, Charlotte Tilbury’s unreal skin impressed, thanks to being impossibly glowy. Several products tested were let down by their shade ranges, however, so, we’re hoping to see some shade extensions soon.

For more must-have complexion products, read our review of the best bronzers

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in