Water companies should be investigated for dry spills, says Labour MP
A BBC investigation suggests that Wessex, Thames and Southern Water have spilled sewage illegally.
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.New shadow environment secretary Steve Reed has called for an investigation into three water companies that may have illegally dumped sewage on dry days following a BBC report.
Water companies are only supposed to spill after heavy rain to prevent the system from backing up and flooding homes and businesses with raw sewage.
But an investigation by the BBC, which looked at data from Wessex, Thames and Southern Water, suggested these companies were discharging sewage on some of the hottest and driest days of 2022.
Other water companies declined to give their data to the BBC because they are already under a criminal investigation by the Environment Agency.
Mr Reed said there should be further investigation into the three named companies to see if they breached the terms of their licence and to assess any environmental damage caused by the spills, while blaming the Conservative Government for allowing it on their watch.
He said: “The Conservatives have allowed our precious waterways to be flooded with sewage, damaging the environment and our local tourism.
“This scandal is their fault. They cut back enforcement and monitoring against water companies releasing this filth, and are now failing to prosecute them when they are blatantly breaking the law.
There must be an immediate investigation into both the breach of the licence and the environmental damage caused
“There must be an immediate investigation into both the breach of the licence and the environmental damage caused. Only then can we expose this illegal pollution and bring those responsible to justice.”
Throughout 2022, Wessex, Thames and Southern Water illegally released sewage on 388 occasions, the BBC’s report suggests, even when much of southern England was in drought and saw the hottest temperatures ever recorded.
All three companies appear to have spilled on July 19 2022, when the temperature topped 40C in some places.
Thames Water only had 62% of its overflows monitored so the actual number of spills is likely to be higher. In contrast, Wessex monitored 91%, and Southern 98%.
The BBC team took sewage spill data and compared it with Met Office rainfall figures to see whether water companies dumped on dry days.
A Wessex Water spokesman said: “This a known issue caused by high groundwater which, unlike rainfall that stops relatively quickly, continues for days or even months. None of these overflows cause rivers to fail to meet ecological standards.
“We’re using nature-based solutions to treat groundwater-affected sites, and by 2025 we will have completed or progressed 28 schemes in our region.
“Meanwhile, we’re investing £3 million a month on reducing overflows, which we agree aren’t fit for the 21st century, and we’re planning to invest significantly more between 2025 and 2030 subject to regulatory approval.”
Water minister Rebecca Pow said the Government is prosecuting water companies that illegally pollute while raising the penalties to an unlimited level and requiring more monitoring of sewage dumping.
She added: “If Labour had a credible plan they’d be using it in Wales where sewage is discharged almost twice as often.
“Sir Keir Starmer and Labour’s only solution to tackling sewage would be to slap more tax on consumers driving up bills.”
If anyone is going to pay for this it should be the shareholders of those companies that have made off with £72 billion of our money and the bondholders who are now reaping the benefits of interest on £60 billion worth of debt
Feargal Sharkey, the punk rock singer-turned-river campaigner, told BBC Breakfast that water companies have already received enough money from customers to fix the sewage issue and therefore bills should not have to go up in consequence.
He said: “Two years ago, the regulator wrote to the water companies. They have a legal obligation to build and operate a sewage system capable of effectively dealing with the content of those sewers.
“They also told the water companies we as customers have already provided them with all the funding they needed to fix this sewage system for the last 30 years.
“So the question we should be asking is, what happened to the money? Where did it go? It clearly wasn’t spent on the sewage system, and can we have a refund?
“If anyone is going to pay for this it should be the shareholders of those companies that have made off with £72 billion of our money and the bondholders who are now reaping the benefits of interest on £60 billion worth of debt.”
Sorting out sewage spills will take investment, which is why the industry has a £10 billion plan – triple the current amount – to upgrade the nation’s sewers
Water UK said that dry spills are not unlawful if groundwater enters private pipes that water companies do not control but which connect to the public system, although the Environment Agency said spills due to groundwater are a breach of permit and illegal, the BBC reported.
A Water UK spokesman said: “There should be no dry spills of sewage into waterways. Ideally, there should be no spills at all.
“Sorting out sewage spills will take investment, which is why the industry has a £10 billion plan – triple the current amount – to upgrade the nation’s sewers.”