TELEVISION / A place to call their own: Thomas Sutcliffe on What Do You Expect - Paradise?
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.YOU braced yourself for What Do You Expect - Paradise? (C 4), Rex Bloomstein's portrait of Arlington House, which accommodates around 400 homeless men in Camden. Anyone who has walked the pavements that surround the great Victorian pile knows that the incidence of incoherent abuse, rambling pledges of affection and slurred chorales are as high as anywhere in London, so it seemed likely that the interior would be something out of Dickens, a sordid warren of decrepit corridors, squalid bedding and unexplained puddles.
What was actually revealed inside was astonishing - a clean, well-maintained hostel in which the dispossessed could find privacy, clean linen, some security and basic human sympathy. The punitive institutional architecture of Victorian benevolence had been partially tamed and the conditions in general would put many hospitals to shame. You never found out whether this is the result of munificent funding from Camden Council or simply exceptional management, but whoever is running the place should be asked to apply their talents a little more widely - they could sort out London's problems first and when that's done turn their attention to the country as a whole.
When it was built, Arlington House was intended to house 1,000 working men - not destitutes but the deserving poor. Now that the rabbit-hutch cubicles have been expanded it will hold just under 400 guests, each of whom will have been interviewed before they are given a room. On the evidence of some conversations in the film this cannot be an easy procedure. How do you interview a man who replies either without the use of consonants or with a medley of Harry Lauder songs? With considerable reserves of patience, I guess, a quality which Bloomstein's touching film also had in large measure.
From the opening scene, in which a sprucely dressed man sang a song to prove that 'everybody here isn't a vagrant', Bloomstein was at pains to listen to the men's account of themselves, narratives shot through with pained candour and self-justification. One man, who had fled from the violence of Northern Ireland said of alcohol that it had given him 'a glimpse of being without fear'.
A former public schoolboy, features now hidden behind a paste- brush beard, pulled tightly on a tiny roll-up as he explained how his father's legacy had run out. He hated alcohol, he declared, though 'I once tried ether - I looked it up in a medical book. It's non-toxic and it gets rid of phlegm on the lungs'. He delivered this with a dry chuckle, a familiar sound in these bitter recollections, sanding the edge off remarks which would otherwise leave splinters in the mind.
'It breaks my heart to look at the bastards,' said another guest. 'I think I'd sooner be in hell.' Then he chuckled too, as though laughing at his own caricature of misery. Another man shook as he described how he had lost his lover through drink, his eyes trembling with tears like an overfilled glass. That you emerged from this hour feeling hopeful says a considerable amount for the businesslike love of those who run Arlington House and for the humane optimism of Bloomstein's regard.
In 'Ghosts in the Dinosaur Graveyard', Horizon (BBC 2) followed a band of American dinosaur hunters to the Gobi desert. They were in part following a celebrated pre-war expedition, a fact brought home by startling echoes of the historical footage in the current film and by the antiquity of some of their vehicles. The scientists' ability to sort bones from stones was little short of miraculous - 'It's a specimen of protoceratops', said one, handling a large lump of shapeless rubble. But then if I drank whisky at the rate they appeared to, maybe I might see dinosaurs too.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments