State of Play, Kevin Macdonald, 127 Mins, 12A

This remake of the TV conspiracy series is a hymn to the newspaper, and to old-fashioned thrillers

Reviewed,Nicholas Barber
Saturday 25 April 2009 19:00 EDT
Comments
(GLEN WILSON)

Your support helps us to tell the story

From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.

At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.

The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.

Your support makes all the difference.

Paul Abbott's six-part BBC drama State of Play wasn't just one of the most acclaimed television events of 2003. It had such a following that it's hard to think of any British series that's garnered better reviews in subsequent years. The prospect of Abbott's labyrinthine yarn being unravelled for a two-hour Hollywood movie, then, is enough to make most right-minded people boycott their local cinema. But fear not, the new State of Play film is no ordinary remake.

It's directed by Kevin Macdonald, the Oscar-winning British director of The Last King of Scotland, and it's co-written by Tony Gilroy, who scripted the Bourne trilogy and Michael Clayton. They're both as skilful as anyone working today at brainy yet mainstream action and adventure, and neither of them tarnishes his reputation here. I can't remember when I last saw a more intelligent, gripping or substantial thriller. Most impressively of all, State of Play doesn't feel like a project that's left over from 2003, but one which evokes the classic paranoid conspiracy thrillers of the Seventies, as well as being bang up to date in its subject matter.

Taking over John Simm's lead role (and filling in for Brad Pitt, who dropped out at the last minute) is Russell Crowe, a Washington newspaper journalist who prefers to do his reporting the old-school way – on the streets rather than on the information superhighway. Compared to his peppy young colleague on the blog desk, Rachel McAdams, Crowe is a dinosaur: a tubby, beardy, shaggy-maned hack who's a dead ringer for Justin Lee Collins from The Friday Night Project. But he could have stumbled on to the story of his career.

He's just started sniffing around two alleyway shootings when he hears about another sudden fatality. The pretty aide of a crusading congressman, Ben Affleck, has either fallen or been pushed in front of an underground train. When Affleck announces her death to the press, he has tears in his eyes, and that's enough to spark rumours of a Clinton-Lewinsky type of working relationship. In a sly montage, gossip mutates instantly into statements of fact on the internet and the rolling news TV channels. For the media, the infidelity is far more noteworthy than the minor business of a young woman's death. But Crowe suspects that it might be linked to the earlier shootings, and they might all be linked to the private military contractors who were being investigated by Affleck and his assistant.

Crowe sees himself as being driven by his thirst for truth, but in State of Play every character has a personal agenda, however heroic they might wish to appear. Crowe's motives are muddied by his history as Affleck's college roommate, and by the fling he had with Affleck's wife, Robin Wright Penn. Meanwhile, his editor, Helen Mirren (in Bill Nighy's BBC role), is less interested in the truth than than by how the revelations will be received by the multimedia corporation that pays her wages. One of the themes that gives the film so much more weight than a standard murder mystery is the rise of cyberspace and the concurrent decline of (sob) the newspaper, a theme far more relevant now than it was when the TV series aired.

More and more characters, ideas and twists keep whizzing along at breathtaking speed, but Macdonald and his writing team keep things admirably lucid, unlike, for instance, a certain recent Bond film. And as outlandish as the plot might be – it is a conspiracy thriller, after all – it always seems to be happening to real people who work in real offices in a real city, with the cluttered desks and graffiti-smeared walls that implies. It's tempting to say that they don't make 'em like this any more. State of Play is, at heart, a tribute to the virtues of old-fashioned newspaper reporting, but it embodies old-fashioned movie-making virtues, too.

Also Showing: 26/04/2009

Outlander (114 mins, 15)

Never mind Monsters vs Aliens, the three-word pitch of Outlander is Vikings vs Aliens, as Jim Caviezel's spaceman crashes in 8th-century Norway with a slavering beastie in the hold. It should be a delirious B-movie, but it plods along with dreary seriousness, despite the fey Vikings' random accents and gleaming white teeth. Rent 2007's Beowulf instead.

Frequently Asked Questions about Time Travel (86 mins, 15)

This sub-Shaun of the Dead Britcom stars Chris O'Dowd, Dean Lennox Kelly and Marc Wootton as three losers who are in the pub when they're approached by Anna Faris, an agent from the future, and soon find themselves zipping back and forth through time. Leaving a distinct impression that it was written in the pub by someone just as geeky as its heroes, it's like one of those Doctor Who episodes that don't focus on the Doctor – except it's twice as long.

The Uninvited (87 mins, 15)

Ludicrously gothic Hollywood remake of Korea's A Tale Of Two Sisters. A teenager (Emily Browning) sees ghosts who tell her, in that cryptic way the undead are so keen on, that her father's girlfriend (Elizabeth Banks) murdered her mother. Given that the family lives in a New England mansion with its own wood and boat house, a few ghosts seems a small price to pay.

Shifty (90 mins, 15)

Two twentysomething geezers (Daniel Mays and Riz Ahmed) mooch around an English high-rise suburb, selling drugs and chatting about old times. The camerawork is dispiritingly uncinematic, but the terrific performances just about compensate. Making his big-screen debut, the magnetic Ahmed deserves to be a star.

The Grocer's Son (96 mins)

A city boy moves back to the absurdly scenic countryside to drive his aged parents' grocery van. Very pleasant and very French.

From Russia with Love (115 mins, PG)

Sean Connery goes to Turkey in his second Bond film. The series' high point? It's certainly the most faithful to the book.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in